In this podventure, we discuss the episode “Back to Bethlehem, Part II,” in which the cast of the nativity expands to include the shepherds and the expecting couple themselves, Mary and Joseph. Hezekiah challenges Eugenius to engage his heart in his search for truth. Mary’s labor begins, and Connie is called upon to assist. Judah approaches Connie with a marriage proposal. Also, a quick look at the discussion questions, some character appreciation, and a daily mantra we hope nobody adopts.