The Illusion of Consensus

Episode 43: Aaron Kheriaty On The Murthy v. Missouri Supreme Court Hearing

04.02.2024 - By Dr. Jay Bhattacharya & Rav AroraPlay

Download our free app to listen on your phone

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

In this episode, Aaron Kheriaty and I discuss our involvement in the Murthy v. Missouri case, which challenges the government's censorship pressures on social media companies. We discuss the censorship we personally experienced and the discovery of government involvement in online censorship. We also discuss the media blackout surrounding the case and the role of legacy media in supporting censorship. The episode concludes with a discussion of the Supreme Court oral arguments and the justices' positions. The conversation delves into the Supreme Court oral arguments in the case challenging government censorship on social media platforms. We generally express optimism that the case will result in a significant victory for free speech. Sound Bites: * "The government had essentially set up what he called an Orwellian ministry of truth." * "This is the worst free speech violation in United States history." * "Throttle everything that's positive about Great Barrington Declaration." Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Personal Experiences with Censorship 06:15 The Scope and Impact of Censorship 10:27 The July 4th Ruling and Constitutional Violations 13:17The Circuit Court's Ruling and Third-Party Censorship 16:46The Appeals Court and Preliminary Injunction 17:26Media Coverage and Economic Interests 20:03The Supreme Court Case and Expectations 24:55 The Twitter Files and Reporting 26:52 The Role of Legacy Media and Censorship 28:59 The ACLU and Professional Medical Societies 32:33 The Supreme Court Experience and Observations 36:21 Reading the Tea Leaves: Justices Kagan, Sotomayor, and Jackson 39:16 Concerning Justices and Compelling State Interest 41:46 The Purpose of the First Amendment 46:00 Government's Spread of Misinformation 46:47 Illusion of Consensus 47:29 Government's Right to Free Speech 48:56 Censorship vs. Speech 49:26 Government's Misinformation 53:24 Section 230 and Liability Protection 58:27 Potential Supreme Court Ruling 01:00:48 Impact of Winning or Losing 01:07:31 Importance of Free Speech

This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.illusionconsensus.com/subscribe

More episodes from The Illusion of Consensus