
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Over the past few months I’ve become increasingly more security and privacy conscious. This has led me to upgrade the tools I use on a daily basis to ones that support my ethos and make some kind of further statement about the world I would like to live in. In this post, I write about the tools I now use and share some thoughts on the society in which I use them. If you’re just after the recommendations, you can skip to those by clicking here.
US Attorney General William Barr claims that ‘making our virtual world more secure should not come at the expense of making us more vulnerable in the real world’, failing to recognise that the virtual and real world are the same thing. Contrary to the popular retort, claiming back my privacy and caring about security is not about ‘having something to hide’, it’s about having something worth protecting: everything. If you had told someone at the dawn of the world wide web that almost every mode of interaction would be mediated by it, they’d probably have called you crazy. It is specifically because they encompass everything we do that security around our digital lives is of paramount importance.
If you doubt that our digital lives have much of a bearing on the real-world, give somebody the password to your email inbox and watch them take control of almost everything you own. Email shouldn’t be – but is treated like – identification. I can log into my bank account with it, I can reset passwords, I can email technical support who will, by pure dint of the fact I am using the email address registered to an account, hand over sensitive security information.
We live in an unprecedented era of surveillance where corporations are joining the State as a privacy and security adversary. These companies are eager to jigsaw the minuscule breadcrumbs of your life in order to sell your data and attention to advertisers. We’ve seen companies abusing their power or being so lackadaisical with the data they gather – frequently with only de-facto consent – that it ends up in the hands of others who are happy to abuse it. Given enough time, becoming the subject of a data breach is almost a given. How severely it impacts you depends on how well you protected your other assets.
We cannot expect governments, corporations, or other large, faceless organizations to grant us privacy out of their beneficence. […] We must defend our own privacy if we expect to have any. – A Cypherpunk’s Manifesto
A lot of the things I’ve done to improve my privacy and security are far beyond what is really required. It’s also worth noting that some of this comes at both a financial and convenience cost and that there’s always a cost-benefit analysis to be done when deciding which of these tools to implement yourself. Historically there has always been a trade-off between security and convenience (as there continues to be between financing tools with our data and financing tools with our money) but as people become more aware of how their data is held and has the potential to be used against them, developers begin to create tools to maximise privacy and minimise the time and effort spent achieving it.
As with everything on this domain, I am not paid nor do I get commission or anything for free by recommending these companies to you. This is an impartial list of the tools I use in my daily life to claw back my privacy and make things more secure. I encourage you to do your own research and work out what tools suit your needs.
Recommendations
I have moved from…
I have adopted use of…
I have turned on…
I have turned off…
Removing stray profiles is something I’ve been doing over the past few months too. Consolidating and reducing my footprint whilst securing everything that remains means there’s less to compromise. I learned this the hard way when HaveIBeenPwned told me an account I hadn’t used since 2012 was part of a data breach in 2018…
If your interest has been piqued, I’ve created a Twitter list that curates the messages of my favourite tools. Feel free to subscribe to it and dig around to find tools that work for you or to email me with suggestions, tips, or to chat further about this topic. I’d love to hear what you think.
For privacy to be widespread it must be part of a social contract. People must come and together deploy these systems for the common good. – A Cypherpunk’s Manifesto
Twitter prides itself on being current. It is not a social network, it is an information network. It is quick, short, sharp and to-the-point and yet despite Twitter’s immediacy it also has an unnecessary permanence. At best, old tweets are of little value. At worst they’re a personal and professional liability.
In July 2016, I had 63,000 tweets. One month later, I had less than 20. There’s a growing body of people who, as Kevin Roose writes, use ‘homegrown methods to make their tweets self-destruct’. I am one of them.
‘Tweets are passing things,’ says Matthew Lazin-Ryder, a Vancouver-based producer with CBC Radio. ‘I don’t laminate and frame my note-pad doodles, why would I preserve my tweets for all time?’
Author and former Twitter employee Robin Sloan also engages in this practice. When asked why he started to delete his tweets, he said:
I assume I was taking a spin back through old tweets and decided, ehh, this is not a great contribution to the historical record.
Noah Kalina, a photographer probably most famous for his ‘Everyday’ project, in which he takes a photograph of himself daily and compiles them into timelapse videos, told me (via tweets now gone) that old social media content does ‘nothing but embarrass’.
I agree. Like Robin, Noah and Matthew, I downloaded my Twitter archive and began looking back at past versions of myself, all the way back to 2009. I hated it so I wiped it and I bet you would too.
Social media does have value in the short-term. Services like Twitter are great for making announcements and having discussions in the same way face-to-face conversation is. But face-to-face conversations are ephemeral, relevant only for as long as you’re having them, so why do we feel the need to keep a copy of conversations online?
Josh Miller, previously a product manager at Facebook and Obama’s White House, wrote a piece of code that deleted his tweets after seven days. He frames his tweet-deleting as a decision to make Twitter more like other forms of conversation…
My opinions aren’t permanent in my head (I often change my mind over time), and they’re not permanent when shared around the dinner table (nobody is recording our conversations),’ Miller wrote in an e-mail. ‘So it just doesn’t make sense to me that they would be permanent online.’
I bet he wishes the present occupier of the White House adopted his stance too.
To decide how long I should leave before my tweets expired, I looked at how long my average tweet was relevant for. In 2016, when I was still a heavy user of Twitter, I decided it would be 72 hours. That was a good time for tweets to be published, read, shared, and begin to die.
I wrote a full-blown cloud-hosted programme to delete my history on a rolling basis, 72 hours after a tweet was posted. I wasn’t deleting a dark history, I was simply using Twitter for its purpose: current conversation. As fantastic as it is, I didn’t join the growing crowd because of Rooses’ article. I joined because I had my own thoughts about Twitter and social media in general.
Not long after my app began deleting my tweets, I stopped using Twitter altogether. It turns out that if you mute every user you follow and trash every tweet you have, there’s very little reason to use the service at all! I’m not sad about that; anyone who has 62,000 tweets has spent too much time on Twitter.
In the middle of 2018, I did the same thing with Facebook. Every like unliked, every share unshared, every post deleted. This felt a lot harder to do. Facebook is where ‘friends’ are, not followers. It’s where photo albums are hosted and event invites are shared. Facebook was my secondary school, it was my Sixth Form, it was my university. But of course, it wasn’t – and the only thing stopping me, much like the first time I deleted my tweets, was a sense of sentimentality. These platforms never were intended to be diaries; the history is incidental and, as recent events testify, potentially dangerous.
When I began deleting my tweets three years ago, social networks were different. News that states were using them to try and sway international elections hadn’t come to light, social media shaming hadn’t really made headlines in the way it inevitably would, and we had no clue that privacy scandal after privacy scandal would beleaguer tech companies in the way it eventually did. In hindsight, these things were obvious. If the Cola Wars of the ’70s and ’80s were about Coke and Pepsi fighting it out for your money, the ’00s and ’10s will be known as the Data Wars. Despite all of this, the social landscape hasn’t meaningfully changed. Facebook has continued to consolidate and kill off competition either by buying them out or by cloning their features – ‘fuck us or we’ll fuck you’ – leaving us in a world with three major platforms, Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram, owned by two companies – Facebook and Twitter – with nothing on the periphery. Snapchat, evidently, got fucked.
I’m sure my past activity on both of these platforms still exists somewhere in the underbelly of the beast and if it does, I am very sure they are still using that activity to sell me as a user to advertisers. The reality, however, is that I’m much less of a valuable asset than someone with an entire back-catalogue of public activity. I’m also less of a liability to myself.
Twitter is a ‘honeypot for assholes’, claims a former employee. They aren’t talking about ordinary people like you and me – but your Twitter archive is a honeypot. It’s a honeypot for the political and socially radicalised, for the company that wants to check you’re a good fit before they’ve even spoken to you, and for hard-pressed journalists looking for a shareable story. All of them will spend hours scanning your online footprint with the explicit purpose of finding something negative. It’s so easy that I’d say it’s probably the first step they take when a new name crosses their desk.
All of this gives credibility to deleting old social media posts as a practice. And believe it or not, Twitter was supposed to be this way.
In Hatching Twitter: A True Story of Money, Power, Friendship, and Betrayal, a book by journalist Nick Bilton about the founding of the network and the lives of the people behind it, co-founder Jack argued Twitter is about updating your personal status and that only one update should be visible at a time. ‘What are you doing?’, the website asked before it changed to ‘What’s happening?’ in 2009.
My relationship with social media (and the internet in general, having grown right on the cusp of ‘everything in your pocket’) has always been muddy. An early adopter of just about every social platform going, my presence on the services had always been ‘this is who I am’ rather than ‘this is what I do’. I now have a more balanced mindset.
To quote Tom MacWright, who deleted his tweets in June 2017:
What I write on my website is the historical record. I’ll use Twitter as usual - an outlet for bad jokes and links to blog posts, but it’ll be a fresh start.
My app still runs on Heroku for free. It’s called Mayfly, named after the insect that lives for just a few hours, even though I’ve now expanded my tweet-then-delete window to 28 days.
The number is still fairly arbitrary but 28 days is the number of days between each of the newsletters I send to my subscribers. I still twitter away my time reading the service and sharing thoughts and photographs every now and then, but it’s a lot less than I ever did before.
Hello, my name is Adam!
I graduated with 1:1 BA (Hons) in Radio Production from the University of Gloucestershire in 2016 and have been producing radio, digital, and design content for the UK's children's radio station, Fun Kids, ever since.
I also freelance as a brand and experience designer, working with clients such as RadioDNS, Digital Radio UK, and Clearwater Hampers. If you'd like to hire me to work on your project, get in touch using the contact details below.
I'm interested in minimalism, sustainability and the environment, and the impact of technology on people and the planet. I'm discovering more about the things that help make life more simple, safe, and private. When I need to deepen my understanding of something, I tend to break it down to a single problem and design either a product or a digital tool to investigate that problem. In the past, I’ve made both a physical and digital clock with a single hand that takes 365 days to complete a revolution, a tool that destroys tweets on a rolling basis, and more.
Ethics and integrity are a couple of my core principles. I find the ongoing assault against privacy an affront which is why I financially and morally support tools that help grant individuals more privacy including zero-knowledge cloud storage and end-to-end encrypted messaging.
I've run social enterprise initiatives with these same values in mind, including a multi-award-winning cider co-operative. Profits went to support local projects including the University of Gloucestershire's Tone Radio – where I spent two years as Head of News and Head of Technical during university – and the All Golds rugby league team. As a member of 1% For The Planet, I continue to support organisations that do good by donating 1% of my income to charities including Greenpeace, Cool Earth, ClientEarth, and more.
On my website and in this podcast I write and talk about a mixture of things including technology and projects I'm working on, as well as hold conversations with people I find influential.
You can find out what I've been up to at the end of each month – including what I've been reading, writing about, and listening to – by becoming a member of my website and subscribing to my monthly email newsletter, Recently.
To stay up to date with my work, follow me on Twitter, subscribe to this podcast, or to my website via RSS.
You can also visit by Now page at /now, where you'll find out what my priorities are as of this very moment.
Contact
I love hearing from people. Introduce yourself via email and say hello – I reply to all courteous people.
Email: [email protected]
Science has proven that meditation increases immunity, decreases pain, increases positive thinking, decreases depression, increases social connection and emotional intelligence and decreases anxiety and stress. It also makes you more compassionate, feel less lonely, and improves your ability to regulate your emotions. Meditation also increases your grey matter, increases focus and creativity, improves your ability to multitask, and even improves your memory. So meditation is pretty good then.
To those who know me, it’s probably no surprise that I meditate, and moving in to my final semester at university, full of deadlines and uncertainty, I suspect I’ll be doing a lot more of it.
The ‘brand image’ of meditation is evolving but some still see it as an activity that involves sitting crossed-legged, robed, chanting in a foreign language. Far from being annoyingly metaphysical, one application – Calm – is setting out to break the misconception.
I had a chat with Michael Acton-Smith, one of Calm’s founding pair, to find out more…
Michael, where did the inspiration for Calm come from?
Alex Tew, my co-founder, has been a life long meditator. I was initially dubious as I thought there were religious and ‘woo woo’ connotations but as I researched more I began to appreciate the science behind it.
Calm is about breaking down the misconceptions of meditation and about making it more relatable. We want to demystify this valuable practice and make it accessible and understandable to all.
A few years ago we had the chance to buy Calm.com and that was the first step in creating an exciting and important new brand. We felt there is an awakening in the West of people who want to understand and develop their minds.
Calm’s audience is ‘anyone with a mind’, and our mission is to make the world a happier and healthier place.
And how is that mission progressing?
Very well. We have over 4 million downloads and are adding about 10,000 new users every day. The feedback we get from users is awe-inspiring and humbling.
We have many plans to expand the brand and bring Calm into all aspects of someone’s life, but the app is the heart of the business. Some ideas include Virtual Reality, clothing, music, and community events around the world.
Lots of meditation practitioners talk about disconnecting from technology and re-connecting to people and nature. What’s the relevance of meditation in the digital age?
These devices we carry with us everywhere are super powerful and valuable but we need to learn to become masters of them rather than slaves. For many people their relationship with their phone is mindless and it’s causing a great deal of stress, distraction and anxiety in the world.
I don’t feel being a technological company has hindered Calm’s success. There are 2 billion smartphones in the world and it is the smartest way to connect with a huge audience. The technology is not at fault it is our relationship with it that matters.
And what does meditation, and Calm, mean to you, Michael?
I started meditating a few years ago and I have observed many benefits in my life. When I discover something I’m passionate about I love turning it into a business and sharing it with the world.
Calm is a very exciting journey that I believe will not only be a successful business but more importantly will help bring a little more peace, perspective and equanimity into the world.
We’re accustomed to seeing a variety of logos on our products. Pick up any item and along with the brand name and variety you’ll also be bombarded with other information: What is it made of? Where was it made? How much does it weigh? What size is it? What’s the nutritional content like? Any potential allergies? How do I dispose of it? How do I store it? How do I wash it? Can I tumble dry it? and so on, and so forth.
There are already logos out there to help consumers distinguish so-called ‘good products’ from bad ones. The Fairtrade Mark is perhaps the most globally recognisable of them all but there’s also the Soil Association’s ‘organic’ certification, the Rainforest Alliance seal to look out for on tea and coffee, and the Forest Stewardship Council’s certification. If you’re in the UK, you might also be familiar with the Red Tractor logo which you can look for on animal, dairy, and fresh produce. The Leaping Bunny logo is the only internationally recognised symbol proudly showing that no new animal tests were used in the development of any product displaying it, and that funny kite-looking symbol on your helmet or smoke alarm is a quality assurance mark given out by the British Standards Institute.
There are hundreds of these things and all of these logos mean something. They’re simple, graphical signifiers that help consumers make better, safer, and more ethical choices, from ensuring fair-pay for workers to supporting better environmental standards, consumers pay attention to these symbols when looking to buy.
Despite all of these symbols – spanning food to window-fittings – I can’t seem to find anything that marks clothes as ‘sweatshop-free’. By that, I mean no money anywhere along the supply chain, from cotton-picking to sewing to screen-printing to shelf-stacking, should go in to the hands of sweatshop owners. I can’t find any symbol that tells me the product I am about to buy has never touched a sweatshop in its creation.
While individual companies proudly tout some of their range as ‘Sweatshop Free’, these companies have differing definitions of what a ‘sweatshop’ is and their criteria for checking and certifying themselves (which is never a good sign anyway) varies wildly.
This isn’t even a new idea. In 1999 Naomi Klein wrote a book called No Logo, in which she expressed the same concerns.
Already, a common imperative is emerging from the disparate movements taking on multinational corporations: the people’s right to know. If multinationals have become larger and more powerful than governments, the argument goes, then why shouldn’t they be subject to the same accountability controls and transparency that we demand of our public institutions? So anti-sweatshop activists have been demanding that Wal-Mart hand over lists of all the factories around the world that supply the chain with finished products.
Klein, however, fears a ‘No Sweat’ logo will become ‘just another logo for the conscientious consumer’. I agree, but consumers, conscientious or not, are people. People who need to eat and buy clothes and as people who need to buy products, buying better and publicising the ways in which to do so is one of our most powerful forms of protest.
Yes, that pretty dress is only be £4. Yes, technically speaking, it has already been made so you wouldn’t be forcing a child to make it for you… but that isn’t how this works. Don’t fuel the need for bad companies to make bad products by buying it. Don’t line their pockets with your hard-earned cash, while your pockets were stitched by people working for as little as 60p per day.
Even with the absence of a centralised and independently certified ‘No Sweat’ logo, we know the companies to avoid. Primark links to an entire page about their ethics, front-and-centre on their website and yet has been littered with plenty of allegations in the past.
If you think sweatshops were just a thing of the nineties, think again. In 2013, disaster struck in Bangladesh. Rana Plaza, a garment factory creating clothes for the likes of Matalan, Primark, Walmart, and Bonmarché, collapsed. 1,135 people died, around 2,500 were injured. The Bangladesh Fire Service said the upper four floors had been built without a permit. The architect, Massood Reza, said the building was planned for shops and offices but not factories.
Primark claim they don’t own the factories, but that doesn’t mean they can wash their hands of the affair. While Primark did compensate families (to the measly sum of $200 USD[*], and only if they could provide DNA evidence that they had lost a relative), prevention is always better than cure.
Lush – the UK-based cosmetics company – has the right stance. They don’t buy products from suppliers who test on animals. Even if they’re buying a totally different product; if the company tests on animals, the company is a no-go. They don’t want to see customer money pouring in to the hands of practices they do not believe in. I think that’s a respectable decision taken by a heavily respected company.
All of the certifications I’ve listed have strict criteria, controls, and checks in place to ensure the company or product is worthy of bearing their mark. I am no expert on sweatshops but allow me to hypothesise the criteria for what a ‘No Sweat’ logo might look like:
There could, of course, be many, many more criteria to measure.
For employers, higher pay means heightened efficiency, a better and more consistent quality of work, stronger employee morale, and, ultimately, retention rates of skilled workers. For employees, higher pay is often a path to the ‘American Dream’ for their families: education, stable employment, and home ownership.
So, the next time you walk in to a high-street store, gander at the price-tag and catch yourself in surprise, ask yourself this:
How can cotton picked in Brazil be packed, shipped and processed in China, stitched in Vietnam, get shipped to Europe for screen-printing, before being shelved in the UK ready for you to buy?
[*] $200USD is about three months wages for a garment worker in Bangladesh. My point is: to multimillion dollar companies like the ones listed, $200 USD is just a nice staff lunch.
‘Defying Conventions: Is Beats 1 Redefining Radio?’ was originally submitted as part of a University of Gloucestershire Radio Production module. With the exception of two small typographical changes, this essay is posted exactly as it was submitted. Appendices have been redacted but bibliography and in-line references remain – get in touch if you need to chase anything.
Apple’s annual World Wide Developer Conference is a showcase of the company’s latest software and technology. Described by CEO Tim Cook as the ‘epicentre of change’, 2015 marked their ‘most global conference ever’ (Apple, 2015), a fitting stage to announce their new ‘worldwide’ and ‘always on’ internet radio station, Beats 1.
The announcement of Beats 1 came as a footnote to an addendum. The presentation mainly dealt with Apple’s latest technological offering, ‘Apple Music’ – a streaming service and social network combined, of which the radio station is merely a subsidiary – rather than with Beats 1 Radio directly. Nevertheless, speaker, record producer, and entrepreneur Jimmy Iovine painted it as a nod to the company’s history; the minds behind the iPod and media software iTunes were returning to the grassroots of music sharing: radio.
This essay will look at the early success and criticisms of Beats 1. It will do this by examining how the station defies established radio theory and is helping to evolve the medium both technologically and stylistically. It will contextualise these findings in the form of current industry practice, as well as what pressures the station may put on commercial and public service radio broadcasting in the United Kingdom. The essay aims to explore the timing and reasons behind the inception of the station and will raise questions behind its ideology. It will draw on a range of practitioner, academic and secondary sources as well as personal listening and theorisation in order to explore whether Apple’s Beats 1 is ‘redefining radio’.
Defining Radio
From the offset, a couple of basic but important distinctions need to be made. As the Radio Advertising Bureau reflect in their 2014 report Audio Now (p.10), new forms of audio are continually emerging. The report highlights three main forms of consumer-level audio, with the latest — ‘on-demand’ — being less than ten years old:
This notion of ‘owned audio’ can be entirely discounted when discussing Apple Music as a standalone product; the user never gets physical access to the music files, just the right to stream them in exchange for a monthly membership fee of £9.99. The second and third definitions – ‘live audio’ and ‘on-demand’ respectively – are vital when addressing Beats 1 and Apple Music’s other ‘radio’-esqué offerings, the definition of which has been somewhat corrupted by modern-day ‘on-demand’ music streaming services.
‘Radio’, as understood by the likes of Spotify, Deezer, Pandora, or similar, is intrinsically different from the traditional and well-established institution of radio broadcasting. This is not to say traditional radio is out-dated – far from it – but that ‘on-demand’ services have appropriated the name of the medium and have used it incorrectly.
There are multiple differences between the two, with the most notable being that the more traditional notion of radio broadcasting features human presence. Chignell (2009, p.33) explains people ‘add meaning’ and context, and also provide a sense of co-presence. This is the complete antithesis of so-called ‘radio stations’ on streaming services which strip broadcasting of its ‘essential element’ (Priestman, 2006, p.36): human-to-human contact. As Corderio (2011, p.499) highlights, there is a long line of radio theorists who contend ‘music playlists, without human interaction, should not be confused with radio’, and that radio can be easily defined as public, point-to-point_s_ broadcasting. Priestman describes the aforementioned, human-bare stations as ‘automated web “jukebox[es]”’ and for the purposes of this essay, these on-demand web-jukeboxes will be called exactly that.
iTunes Radio – the 2013 predecessor of Apple Music – was one such service. Allowing users to create ‘stations’ around a single artist or band, algorithms mixed content from one band with similar material by similar artists. As Baldwin (2013) reports, iTunes Radio let users ‘rate the songs (…) as they stream[ed]’, thereby learning individual preference in order to modify the output to better suit taste. While iTunes Radio was by no means a failure, algorithms, as Iovine himself admits, ‘can’t do it alone’ (Dredge, 2015). While movements in the realm of acoustic and computer science are moving in the right direction, machines currently fail to recognise mood, thus playing inappropriate or mismatched tracks sequentially, and cannot provide all important context.
Enter Apple Music. While the newer service still contains web-jukeboxes, Apple makes a clear point of distinguishing Beats 1 Radio from them. In the native Music application on iOS, a graphic inviting people to ‘Listen Now’ takes centre stage (appendix; a), occupying well over 50% of the screen space. Not only does this force automated-jukebox stations to exist several swipes away but it also separates Beats 1 from these lesser-refined services. The Beats 1 landing page on the Apple website makes a further point of highlighting this distinction by defining the true meaning of radio itself: ‘No matter where you are or when you tune in, you’ll hear the same great programming as every other listener’ (2015b). This reinforces a concept Chignell (2009, p.74) writes about, co-presence, a theory Scannell and Cardiff (1991) highlight, imagined community, and Marshal McLuhan’s Global Village, ‘one world connected by an electronic nervous system’ (Stewart, n.d.). Irrespective of scale, collective listening is precisely what radio is all about.
As a technology company, there are technological considerations to take in to account when defining what ‘radio’ means to Apple. As the smartphone market leader (Forbes, 2015), it is fitting of Apple to create a station that is marketed at, and primarily received on, mobile devices.
According to a 2015 report from the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry, the digital music industry is worth $6.85 billion worldwide per annum (IFPI, p.6), with ‘music subscription services’ accounting for 22.75% of revenue. On the other hand, ‘radio is a massive $20 billion industry’ (Truong, 2015). At a time where physical format sales are declining (IFPI, 2015b), where the revenue share of music streaming is growing exponentially, and where radio is still ‘able to command the largest share of the listening ear’ (Lloyd, 2015, p.293), Apple wants in.
Moreover, there are some strong statistics to suggest mobile listening is quick becoming a force to be reckoned with. ‘31 minutes a day is the average amount of time spent listening to music on a phone’, Global (2015) claims, and ‘65% of “digital audio” streamers’ – both live audio and on-demand consumers – ‘listen with head[/ear]phones’. Undoubtedly, radio is an intimate and personal medium, esteemed by consumers (McLeish, 2016, pp.3 to 6). To further emphasise this, by interacting through earphones, listeners are choosing to place broadcasters in their ears, to make the broadcast a part of their body, a sacred trust and one only radio could garner. Global also claim ‘44% of 35-44 year-olds’ stream music over tablet devices. Logically, what with early adoption rates and increased technological competence in younger generations who have grown up with this hardware from an early age, this number will only be higher in the 15 to 24 and 25 to 34 demographics, precisely the age of consumer Apple is attempting to capture with Beats 1 Radio.
Defying Radio
In the words of both Finer (2003, p.32) and Castelles (2003, p.17), the internet is the world’s first international radio frequency. Apple not only advertise Beats 1 as being ‘worldwide’, but as ‘a truly global listening experience’, letting audience members discover ‘what’s going on in the world of music’. While parts of this statement are correct – the station can be received in 100 countries around the world (Apple, 2015c), although that is only 51% of the planet – the overall sentiment could not be further from the truth.
At present, the BBC World Service is the world’s largest international broadcaster (House of Commons, 2010, ev.11) serving over 188 million people per week (BBC, 2009). Whilst the on-air content of each station cannot be compared – the BBC World Service is primarily a news and informational platform, while Beats 1 is purely a music station – there are, in terms of scale, many similarities. Evident from its marketing decisions and branding, Apple’s goal is for Beats 1 to adopt an audience of ‘World Service’ magnitude – ‘truly global’, ‘worldwide’. However, in the same way Beats 1 broadcasts from exclusively Western locations – New York City, London, and Los Angeles – yet claims it is a ‘global’ voice, the BBC World Service soldiers in a similar vein. The Operating Agreement of the World Service (BBC Trust, 2012, p.6) sets out English language services as their ‘core offer’ and designates 75% of overall output worldwide to English language programming each week. Even the name of the BBC World Service contains a jarring juxtaposition, seating ‘British’ and ‘World’ two words apart.
On the other hand, ‘beats’ – acoustically speaking – know no borders and are not unique to any specific genre of music. Here, Beats 1’s lack of cultural identity, as far as the name of the station and the simplistic graphical signifiers and branding it uses, allows the station to be transient in nature. However, as O’Malley (2015) reflects, this ‘ill-defined genre remit’ hasn’t come without criticism –
He goes on to state ‘if you make content so broad, it becomes meaningless’. Beats 1 contradicts Priestman’s (2006, p.233) argument that ‘web radio works best as a narrow-cast or niche medium’ and Nyre’s argument (2008, p.192) that music radio stations attempt ‘to attract niche audiences’.
Roy Martin, managing editor of Radio Today, claims Beats 1 threatens ‘specialist music stations such as 1Xtra, Kiss [and BBC Radio] 6 Music’ (2015). The breadth of music these stations play is replicated on Beats 1 without advertisements or pressures to fill remit goals. Contrasting Martin’s sentiment, BBC Radio 1’s controller Ben Cooper – who has lost two talents: Head of Music George Ergatoudis to Spotify (Lunden, 2015) and Lowe to Apple – claims ‘a rising tide lifts all boats’ (Griffiths, 2015). Martin continues, ‘the likes of Radio Plymouth, The Bee [Lancashire] and Clyde 1 [Glasgow]’ need not feel at risk, despite Beats 1 being billed as ‘the world’s local station’ (Quartz, 2015). Although Beats 1 can attempt to masquerade as local radio, when it comes to discussing truly local news and events, even at its closest level of inspection Beats 1 has to take a national view for fear of alienating other listeners. Locality is what makes radio work and Beats 1, with its syndicated, single, linear programming which never once breaks out in to local titbits, cannot possibly achieve the same effect on its desired scale.
The on-air content of Apple’s Beats 1 behaves as a BBC Radio 1Xtra and Radio 6 Music hybrid. The station is clearly attempting to promote ‘challenging, innovative’ (BBC Trust, 2012b, p.2) music, with a distinctive focus on ‘contemporary black music (…) rarely heard elsewhere’ (BBC Trust, 2015, pp.2 to 4), as the aforementioned BBC stations also reflect in their respective remits. Introducing challenging music comes with the need to reason track selection and explain why the creation deserves respect. BBC Radio 6 Music achieves this through interviews and technical discussions, many of which deconstruct musical theory, and through detailed back-announcements that may include the name of record labels, similar musicians, and artist influences. BBC Radio 1 Xtra achieves the same effect by discussing the artists’ potential influence in relation to black British culture. This form of education, required by remit, is evident in the plays-per-day of each station, with BBC Radio 6 Music totaling an average of 172 plays per day and 1Xtra averaging 159 (Last FM, 2016, 2016b). The breaks are filled with news, documentaries and interviews. This is a stark contrast to Beats 1, a station that plays an average of 300 songs per weekday, peaking to 600 on weekends due in part to ‘high-track-turnover DJ mix shows that play during prime party hours’ (Quartz, 2015).
The on-air schedule of Apple’s Beats 1 Radio is unlike any other station. Those familiar with radio will be aware of dayparting, ‘the practice of segmenting the broadcast schedule in to blocks (…) programmed for unique audience demographics and listeners’ daily habits’ (Piasek, 1998). Dayparting helps broadcasters provide more of that all-important context Chignell (2009, p.33) discusses. Nielsen Audio (2015, p.23), one of several U.S. audience rating services, divides a weekday into five such parts. Having slightly adjusted the times for an audience based in the United Kingdom, those dayparts are as follows:
James Cridland believes (2015) ‘it makes no sense putting the money into a great breakfast show (…) because the timezones mean it’s always breakfast somewhere’. Beats 1 replays its three flagship programmes – Zane Lowe, Ebro Darden, and Julie Adenuga – on a twelve-hour loop, thus hitting both eastern and western-based audiences with all three shows in any given 24-hour period. The rest of the schedule is comprised of irregular and one-off programmes fronted by musicians from Elton John to HAIM, and organisations like Noisey and Pitchfork. This pre-recorded content, masquerading ‘as live’, is broadcast at times relevant to the market Apple is attempting to target. For example, St. Vincent’s programme is played at 3 a.m. GMT, 7 p.m. PST (American East-Coast) and 11 a.m. CST (Mainland China), evidently targeting listeners in the Americas and Asia rather than the United Kingdom.
Whilst this may seem a strange idea, it works. One of radio’s early strengths, the art of ephemeral broadcasting, is being eroded in the age of podcasting, ‘owned audio’ and ‘on-demand’. With this comes a pressure for more refined content – producers now must craft sound not only for initial impact, but also for replay value. Transmitting great content once then losing it to the ether is neither cost effective nor clever.
LBC – a commercial, London-based news and talk station – is one of the first in the United Kingdom to implement pay-for catch-up services. Subscription services on a rolling monthly basis cost £3.99 (AudioAgain, 2014). In comparison, Beats 1 offers the same catch-up method: pay to become an Apple Music member. ‘While it doesn’t quite provide the experience of listening to the show live, (…) every DJ will post a set playlist for their show a few hours after it ends’ (iMore, 2015). Most commercial radio stations are yet to offer on-demand catch-up services at all, but some, like Fun Kids – the UK’s only radio station aimed at under-12s – have in excess of 80 podcast channels (Think Fun Kids, n.d.). It is as-of-yet unclear whether the pay-for catch-up model works well enough to warrant the long-term investment required by commercial radio stations in order to develop distribution platforms. However, empowering the consumer through this medium provides another point-of-entry to the station and rewards active consumers with the opportunity to replay their favourite moments from past programmes, or to store the show for posterity.
Given the high profile musicians Beats 1 has access to and the respective fan-bases of those musicians, Apple’s move is clearly another call to subscribe. Once an interview or programme has been broadcast, the only way for dedicated fans to hear that content again – or catch-up, if they missed it first time around – is to pay. Apple know many fans have a fear of missing out, desperate to hear content from their favourite creators, therefore can reasonably assure themselves a select number of subscribers by providing exclusive content hidden behind paywalls.
Redefining Radio
Being owned by a multinational, technological giant has its advantages. While the equipment Beats 1 uses to broadcast is the same as any other digital radio station, the techniques are certainly groundbreaking. Beats 1 is available in two stream formats, 64 kbps and 256 kbps (Painter, 2015) AAC, superior to DAB’s MP2 streams which vary from 64 kbps – for stations including Absolute Radio, Amazing Radio and BBC Radio 5 Live – to 192 kbps – used exclusively by BBC Radio 3 (Laird, 2015). With concern to mobile devices, where the vast majority of stations stream second-by-second, Beats 1 utilises the new HLS streaming format. HLS is HTTP Live Streaming, a new communications protocol developed and implemented by Apple (2014). Designed to be adaptive, devices request stream information in packets of varying quality, and, if at any point diminished bandwidth or download speed causes stress to the stream, devices will request the next packet in a lower quality. This creates the effect of zero buffering, allowing for a smooth and more dynamic listening experience.
The highly customisable nature of mobile phones makes this next statistic hard to measure but assuming a couple of reasonable conditions – that a user has biometric Touch ID enabled and has not moved the Music application from the factory default setting in their iPhone’s docking bar – an ordinary mobile user can become a Beats 1 listener in only four taps. If Siri’s newer hands-free function – ‘Hey Siri’ – is enabled, a user can become a listener without even having to touch their device (appendix; b).
In stark contrast to popular radio streaming applications such as TuneIn or RadioPlayer – two of numerous for desktop and smartphone – Apple forces consumers to use their dedicated Music application in order to hear Beats 1. The reason behind this decision is simple: Apple is a lover of control; proven by the fact Beats 1 audio steams are encrypted. The keys to decrypt the audio streams lay within the Music application itself. When addressing Apple’s design decisions, the company has previously been accused of attempting to create a ‘totalitarian monoculture’ (Bissell, 2008), a statement that is hard to defend Apple against. Indeed, in order for a listener to switch from Apple’s Beats 1 to a potential rival – say, BBC Radio 1 or Capital FM – they would have to conduct at least eighteen further interactions with their device, first by launching a non-native iPhone application, then by having to search for the station before launching it, an overwhelming contrast in user-friendliness from the potential hands-free starting of Beats 1. Matt Deegan – radio practitioner and Creative Director of Folder Media – emphasised this, explaining the inception of Beats 1 is a move to ‘keep people in the Apple Music ecosystem’ (University of Gloucestershire, 2015).
On December 29th 2015 it was reported (RadioToday) Beats Electronics LLC., a division of Apple and the owners of the Beats brand, had put in a bid to internationally trademark the names of four potential new stations, Beats 2 through 5 and respective station logos ‘B2’ through ‘B5’. Whilst Apple has made their intention to expand its radio arm clear (Billboard, 2015), it is unknown whether the filings are just a protective measure to prevent others piggybacking the Beats Radio brand.
In the United Kingdom, the government-approved communications and competition regulator Ofcom, can step-in to ensure monopolies of broadcasting remain fair. If a station like Beats 1 wanted to broadcast on FM, AM, or even DAB, there’s a high likelihood that Apple – with their marketing budget in excess of $1 billion USD (United States Securities and Exchange Commission, 2012) and end-goal of creating several ‘Beats’-branded stations – would not be in receipt of an license. This is where broadcasting solely online has measureable advantages, namely in the lack of regulation. Under the sole condition Apple pays for the rights to stream music in the 100 countries Beats 1 is playable from, there are no further restrictions.
Although indecency regulations do not apply to its online streams, Apple still chooses to play non-explicit, clean, radio-edited versions of tracks 24/7. ‘[C]ensoring explicit language could be a matter of playing it safe rather than hoping the content flies everywhere it’s played,’ Kastrenakes (2015) believes, ‘it’s likely a way to stay in advertisers’ good graces — and it’s certainly possible that ads will show up on Beats 1 eventually, especially since it’s available for free’, he adds. Where a track has a particularly high number of expletives, presenters signpost the non-censored version as ‘now streaming on Apple Music’, a call to subscribe to the service for uncensored content ‘as the artist intended’.
As Priestman (2006, p.3) reminds us, ‘[r]adio was supposed to mean the end of newspapers [and] television was supposed to mean the end of radio’, but as is now evident, newer mediums change their predecessors but do not replace them. Criticism aside, Apple has made some logical additions to the visual and multimedia assets accompanying radio. Beats 1’s metadata – ‘data that provides information about other data’ (Merriam Webster, n.d.) such as what is playing on the station – is visualised on the iPhone lock-screen (appendix; c, d). If users are Apple Music subscribers they can ‘favourite’ tracks, add them to personal playlists for offline ‘on-demand’ streaming, and share the station via social media channels.
Moreover, the synergy Apple’s Beats 1 manages to achieve by embedding its content within the native Music application is unrivalled. Presenters regularly direct listeners to their ‘Connect’ pages – the social networking arm of Apple Music – to see content complimentary to on-air discussions. Apple’s monopolistic attitude over its content pays-off here, where the dynamo and fluidity of content publishing aids the sense of liveness.
While it is clear to see Apple have brought many innovations to the worlds of technology and of music – and is continuing to experiment, along with on-demand streaming services, with the power of radio – I am unconvinced Beats 1 poses a threat to traditional notions of radio broadcasting. I believe Apple has missed a trick by failing to make the station more revolutionary.
The stream is ‘live’ but its DJs are not, the station is ‘global’ but radio works best locally. It is entirely within Apple’s capabilities to syndicate international programming with local break-offs, in the same way Heart FM syndicates a national breakfast show with regional news and travel. Similarly, Apple could easily syndicate its presenters across several genres of station, unifying links but playing different tracks, thus narrowcasting to niche audiences while still maintaining an overall brand identity. Absolute Radio’s ‘Project Banana’, piloted during Christian O’Connell’s breakfast show, adopts this method, handing consumers the power to ‘choose the music to suit their tastes, while enjoying and interacting with the show’s hosts’ live (MediaWeek, 2014).
While the station certainly has had success in marketing itself as a ‘breakthrough’, in the words of James Cridland (2015) ‘I’m not sure it’ll set the world on fire’. Moreover, the move to launch a radio station has attracted many critics, one of which stated it was ‘a terribly exclusive vanity project’ (O’Malley, 2015), a statement I’m inclined to agree with. Matt Deegan is correct; Beats 1 is an advertising space for Apple Music, and contains measureable disadvantages for non-subscribers.
Nevertheless, Beats 1 does pose serious questions for Station Managers and Radio Futurologists alike, namely around sharing multimedia content, ideas of exclusivity and privilege, and scheduling for maximum impact. Where Beats 1 excels, such as in technological competence and innovation, it is my opinion more traditional stations fall far behind. Here, they really are ‘redefining radio’. In this digital age, stations need to strive for technological excellence and Beats 1 is a prime example. This is not shocking, as the biggest and most valuable technology company in the world owns Beats 1.
It is just a shame that, as far as content is concerned, where other stations excel, Beats 1 misses the boat. It comes across clumsy and mismatched, alienating and lazy, rather than the inclusive, ‘worldwide’, gritty and new-age aesthetic it needs to succeed.
–
Bibliography
Apple (2014) ‘HTTP Live Streaming Overview’ On: iOS Developer Library [Accessed 01 January 2016]
Apple (2015) Apple – WWDC 2015. [Online Video], 15 June. [Accessed 01 October 2015]
Apple (2015b) Music: Radio [Online] [Accessed 01 October 2015]
Apple (2015c) Availability of Apple Music, Apple Music Radio, and iTunes Match [online] [Accessed 01 October 2015]
AudioAgain (2014) LBC Podcasts [online] [Accessed 21 January 2016]
Baldwin, R. (2013) ‘Apple Dials in iTunes Radio, a New Streaming Music Service’; Wired. [online] [Accessed 24 November 2015]
BBC (2009) ‘BBC’s international news services attract record global audience of 238 million’ On: BBC Press Office. [online] [Accessed 05 January 2015]
BBC Trust (2012) Operating Agreement: BBC World Service [online PDF] [Accessed 08 December 2015]
BBC Trust (2012b) BBC 6 Music Service Licence [online PDF] [Accessed 30 December 2015]
BBC Trust (2015) 1Xtra Service Licence [online PDF] [Accessed 15 January 2015]
Billboard (2015) Apple Could Launch Five More Beats Radio Stations, According to Report [online][Accessed 10 December 2015]
Bissell, M. (2008) ‘The Totalitarian Regime of Apple’ On: Michael Bissell [online] [Accessed 04 January 2016]
Castells, M. (2003) The Rise Of The Network Society, The Information Age: Economy, Society And Culture, 2nd edn. Blackwell: Oxford.
Chignell, H. (2009) Key Concepts in Radio Studies. Sage: London
Cordeiro, P. (2012) ‘Radio becoming r@dio: Convergence, interactivity and broadcasting trends in perspective’ In: Participations; Journal of Audience & Reception Studies; Vol. 9, Iss. 2, pp. 492 to 510.
Cridland, J. (2015) ‘What We Can Learn From Beats 1’ On: RadioInfo [Online][Accessed 24 Oct 2015]
Cridland, J. (2015b) ‘What People Are Saying About Apple Music and Beats 1’ On: RadioInfo [Online] [Accessed 24 Oct 2015]
Dredge, S. (2015) ‘Apple Music intervieiw: ‘Algorithms can’t do it alone – you need a human touch’; The Guardian [online] [Accessed 24 November 2015]
Finer, J. (2003) Longplayer. Artangel: London.
Forbes (2015) Apple Surpassed Samsung As Global Phone Market Leader, Says Report [online] [Accessed 15 December 2015]
Global (2015) ‘An Audio Revolution’ [online PDF] [Accessed 23 December 2015]
Griffiths, S. (2015) ‘Apple Beats 1: Why is Apple bothering with radio?’ On: BBC News [online] [Accessed December 29 2015]
House of Commons [Foreign Affairs Committee] (2010) The Work of the BBC World Service 2008–09 – Third Report of Session 2009–10 [online PDF] [Accessed 08 January 2016]
IFPI (2015) ‘IFPI Digital Music Report 2015: Charting the Path to Sustainable Growth’ On: IFPI [online PDF] [Accessed 19 January 2016]
IFPI (2015b) IFPI Global Statistics [online] Available at: <> [Accessed 19 January 2016]
iMore (2015) ‘How to listen to Beats 1 shows you’ve missed’ On: iMore. [online] [Accessed 21 January 2016]
Kastrenakes, J. (2015) ‘Apple is playing censored songs on Beats 1’ On: The Verge.[Accessed 21 January 2015]
Laird, J. (2015) ‘Why DAB radio in the UK is broken, and how to fix it’ On: TechRadar [online] Available at: <> [Accessed 30 December 2015]
Last FM (2016) ‘BBC Radio 6 Music Scrobble Library’ On: Last FM [online] [Accessed 18 January 2016]
Last FM (2016b) ‘BBC Radio 1 Xtra Music Scrobble Library’ On: Last FM [online] [Accessed 18 January 2016]
Lloyd, D. (2015) How To Make Great Radio. Biteback Publishing: London.
Lunden, I. (2015) ‘Spotify Poaches BBC Radio Exec In Push For Localised, Curated And Undiscovered Content’ On: TechCrunch [online] [Accessed 02 January 2016]
Martin, R., On: RadioToday (2015) Trademarks made for more Beats radio stations On: RadioToday [online] [Accessed 28 December 2015]
MediaWeek (2014) ‘Absolute Radio launches UK’s first tailored music service, dubbed ‘Project Banana’’ On: MediaWeek [online] [Accessed 20 January 2016]
Merriam Webster (n.d.) Definition: ‘Metadata’ [online] [Accessed 21 January 2016]
Nielson Audio (2015) Nielsen Monitor-Plus™ Methodology by Medium [online PDF] [Accessed 01 January 2016]
Nyre, L. (2008) Sound Media, From Live Journalism To Musical Recording. Routledge: London.
O’Malley, J. (2015) ‘Apple Music’s Beats 1 Radio Station is Just a Terrible Executive Vanity Project’ On: Gizmondo [Online] [Accessed 24 October 2015]
Painter, L (2015) ‘Apple Music FAQ: How to set up Apple Music, cancel your subscription, share an account, find tracks you’ve played in Apple Music’ On: MacWorld [online] [Accessed 20 December 2015]
Piasek, J., In: Godfrey, D. and Leigh, F. (1998) Historical Dictionary of American Radio. Greenwood Publishing: Portsmouth, US.
Priestman, C. (2006) Web Radio: Radio Production for Internet Streaming. Focal Press: Oxford.
Radio Advertising Bureau [RAB] (2014) Audio Now. [online] [Accessed 01 December 2015; PDF hard copy retained and available on request]
Scannell, P., and, Cardiff, D. (1991) A Social History of British Broadcasting, vol. 1: 1992-1939. Blackwell: Oxford.
Stewart, W. (n.d.) ‘Marshall McLuhan Predicts The Global Village’ On: Living Internet [online] [Accessed 20 January 2016]
Think Fun Kids (n.d.) ‘Podcasts’ [online] [Accessed 19 January 2016]
Truong, A. (2015) ‘Radio is a massive $20 billion industry, and Apple wants in’ On: Quartz [online] [Accessed 20 December 2015]
United States Securities and Exchange Commission (2012) Form 10-K, Apple Inc. ANNUAL REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934. [online] Published at Washington D.C.: United States.
University of Gloucestershire (2015) Media Festival Lecture: Matt Deegan of Folder Media. [Digital hard copy retained and available upon request]
Quartz (2015) ‘We analyzed a month of Beats 1 tracks to figure out Apple’s taste in music’ On: Quartz [online] [Accessed 12 January 2016]
Through a tiny little Cotswold village and down a single-file country lane exists one of Gloucestershire’s best cider producers. Based in the tiny civil parish of Awre, Severn Cider and Perry is a family-run business shared across three generations.
Since 1956, they’ve been making cider at their family home-turned-cider mill. Boasting over eight different varieties of drink, this small outfit are the winners of countless regional and national awards, have sold-out of their handcrafted beverages for the past two years, and are even looking to send their produce abroad.
Made on-site from the juice of local heritage apples and pears, the company sits on an idyllic countryside retreat you simply must take some time out to visit. Tucked away among cottages and forged well from the beaten track, you’d be forgiven for thinking the premises is well hidden, but its owner, Nick Bull, explained his small bungalow and unassuming barn were ‘the centre of his world’, and rightly so.
I had a chat with one of Severn Ciders’ Directors, Tom Bull, about the company his family is building. We walked around his home, toured their presses and storage facilities, stood underneath a blossoming Box Kernel tree and spoke at length, through minute April showers, about apples, alcohol, and always pushing the boundaries…
The Bull family began making cider as a family tradition. May Bull – husband of Nick, mother of Tom, and father-in-law of Severn Cider’s founder, Phillip – explained that their hobby business quickly turned in to a domestic industry. Opening its doors to the public in 2009, the family now create thousands of bottles of cider and perry each year.
The apples, all of which are hand-picked from within a thirty-mile radius of the brewery, come from orchards that have been neither sprayed nor fertilised in order to produce a drink that is free from harmful chemicals. Moreover, the juice has nothing added or removed.
The question everyone wants the answer to: how does an apple become alcohol?
Tom explained that after being hand-picked, the apples are washed and sorted ready for milling and processing. The mill smashes the apples to a puree before they’re transferred to the press which squeezes out juices. What’s left is a mush of pulp – something I can only describe as a flapjack of compressed apple, given out to local farms to be biodigested. The juice is then transferred to containers where it sits… waiting patiently.
That’s where this photograph comes from. Just off to the right sit four huge tankers of cider, floor-to-ceiling. Behind those four tankers sit another four, and another four, continuing as far as the eye can see, right to the back of a warehouse I’m guessing is about the size of a football pitch. ‘If we’re talking half-litre bottles, there’s a couple of hundred thousand here, I suppose’, Tom explains. By the way, the place smells fantastic.
Meanwhile, the juice matures on its own natural yeasts, breaking down the sugars and turning it in to alcohol. When the cider has reached its peak, it is flushed from the tankers to newly-cleaned ones for storage. From there, the liquid is syphoned off to oak casks, ready for bottling.
Carefully conserving and propagating their trees, the family have even managed to save one critically endangered fruit, the Box Kernel, from extinction. Grafting and budding the last remaining Box Kernel tree in the parish, a number of trees now exist, used by the family to brew Box Kernel cider. Tom assures me it tastes delicious and I have no reason to doubt him.
Severn Cider and Perry are the producers of Core Blimey, the Students’ Union run social enterprise at the University of Gloucestershire. They supply us with white-label stock which we rebrand and sell as our own – we’ve won awards for it, just like Severn Cider has!
I’m a bit late letting you all know, but Core Blimey Cider – the University of Gloucestershire’s social-enterprise that I’ve been working on for the past year – won Tone Radio an award earlier this week!
In October, Silas – the Students’ Union Social Enterprise Co-Ordinator – and I, rebranded Core Blimey – a 6.4% medium-sweet cider, brewed locally by Severn Cider – as ‘Tone Radio Cider’, and started flogging it.
It formed part of a marketing campaign to re-link the student radio station to university values and acted a nudge to both the Students’ Union and university that their social-enterprises are worthwhile, and that they should keep them alive at all costs.
I like to think we’ve proven their value.
On a whim, I entered the cider in to the I Love Student Radio Awards. The I Love Student Radio Awards is held annually at the National Student Radio Conference and aims to celebrate the commitment and contributions of individuals to student radio. They say ‘it is [for] those people and stations who go the extra mile, putting in time effort and creativity behind the scenes, and whose commitment to student radio is unprecedented.’
Anyway, we got nominated…
And then we won!
Here’s a little extract from our 1,000 word entry. I think it sums up why the cider has done so well:
The Student Radio Association called Core Blimey ‘One of the coolest things we’ve seen in student radio’ in a Facebook post, while Matt Deegan said the cider showcased ‘real thoughtfulness about the link between location, audience, and brand awareness’.
When I speak of this thing called Longplayer to people, I tend to get one of two reactions: amazement, or bemusement. Both respectable, because Longplayer isn’t your average piece of music – and Jem Finer, the composer behind it all, isn’t your average musician. While contemporary songs sit comfortably around the four-minute mark, Longplayer is a single composition with a track duration of one-thousand years.
Starting 12:00 UTC on the 31st of December 1999, Longplayer aims to continue without repetition until the last moment of 2999. Composed for singing bowls – whose resonances can be very accurately reproduced in recorded form – Longplayer is designed to be adaptable to unforeseeable changes in its technological and social environments, and to endure as a long-term and self-sustaining institution.
I’ve known of the project for several years and have, in my own way, become somewhat obsessed with it. To me, Longplayer explores time in a neutral medium, one that everyone can appreciate and understand: sound. After repeatedly dipping in and out of the project – occasionally checking back for developments here-and-there – I was left with questions, and Finer, who spoke to me over the phone after an appointment earlier this month, was more than happy to answer them…
‘I’ve always been obsessed with the vertiginous nature of time… It stretches back to being a kid and being told things we can’t comprehend,’ Jem recalls, remembering that as a child time just felt longer. Children are ‘at the mercy of adults’, “just a minute” turns in to hours, and years seem to feel like forever. ‘Longplayer was a result of trying to feel and understand time,’ Finer told me. To give time – as ironic as it sounds – space.
Longplayer’s major catalyst was the impending millennium. ‘In the mid-1990’s I started reading about plans to celebrate 2000, none of which seemed to have anything to do with thousand-year long stretches of time – more to do with a few weeks of expensive celebration.’ Indeed, one of the original listening posts for Longplayer, situated just across the river from Trinity Buoy Wharf Lighthouse, where the instillation currently lies, is the Millennium Dome. Finer took real gripe against the Dome’s construction, saying ‘it just didn’t feel right. What’s a building got to do with celebrating one-thousand years?’
Jem came up with the seedling that would eventually grow to become Longplayer at the back of a tour bus. Playing around with computer programs, he was looking to make music that would, in essence, compose itself. Drawing in to MIDI and DAW software like Logic, Finer would create short pieces of noise that would slowly fall in-and-out of time. This is exactly how Longplayer works today. Six twenty-minute audio clips, each a slightly different pitch, progress in stages. Behaving almost like planets – in perfect alignment at the start of the piece – the music works in cycles, each clip restarting every two minutes, slightly advanced from where it left off. When heard in real-time, the result is mesmerising – and moving. It wasn’t until later Finer realised that, in theory, this method of composing music could stretch endlessly.
Nobody needs reminding that one-thousand years is a very long time. You also don’t need reminding that people die.
What happens when all those people die?
Jem laughed. Longplayer is currently in the care of a charitable trust, governed by a handful of people. The project is built with survival methods in mind, from human to mechanical performance – their recently released iPhone app even synthesises the music offline, adopting a biological ‘multiply to survive’ approach – but what I wasn’t expecting was the poignancy of Jem’s answer. This is was his brainchild and the entire purpose of Longplayer. He’s had almost twenty years to think about its survival.
While technological methods are certainly options the Longplayer Trust has begun to explore, Jem admits their not his first preference. That’s not what he sees the project to be. ‘Why should it continue if people don’t want it to?’ he posed. ‘Longplayer shouldn’t play because it has to, it should play because people want it to’. Finer’s seeking active participation rather than passive listening.
This reliance on people has extended far beyond simply thinking of ways to keep the music playing. Finer admits that ‘when the music started, I thought I was done’ but acknowledges his thinking couldn’t have been more wrong. As a matter of fact, the project has spawned all kinds of small additions and spin-offs. In September 2009, Longplayer took a giant step forward with its first-ever live performance. The 17-hour event spanned 1,000 minutes of its 1000-year long duration, from 08:00 on the morning of the 12th until 00:40 on the morning of the 13th. More than 7 years in planning, the debut of Longplayer Live introduced its partially-completed instrument – six rings of singing bowls – played by a twenty-six-strong team of musicians.
‘I won’t ask you what the long-term future of Longplayer is, especially as we’re less than 2% of the way through, but are there any developments planned in the near future?’ I asked. Longplayer is a constant state of flux. It’s easy to forget projects like this cost time and money, and Finer admitted that ‘yet again, we’re at a state where we need to secure more funding’. The core-elements of the project, its website, the internet stream, and its home, all cost ‘huge sums of money’. I’m Head of Technical at a radio station and managing just the audio stream is a feat so know these things aren’t easy or cheap, but I’m sure the idea can inspire philanthropists to donate to its cause, even if it is just for legacy.
Legacy was the last question I asked Jem about. Was this just some vanity project to ensure his name went down in the history books and that his work was remembered, or does Longplayer have real, deep-seated meaning? Let me quash your concerns now. The latter is true. Jem doesn’t see Longplayer as ever leaving a legacy because ‘legacy’ suggests the work is over. Theoretically, Longplayer will never end, it will just repeat in one-thousand year cycles. Conceptual artwork and piece of music combined, with a clear and strong message behind it, whatever ‘legacy’ Longplayer leaves, I believe it to be a powerful one – and Jem certainly isn’t in this for himself.
At the exact second this blog post was published, and as much of the world welcomes 2016, Longplayer ticked over into its sixteenth year.
Longplayer is a permanent instillation at Trinity Buoy Wharf, London. You can visit every Saturday and Sunday between the hours of 11am and 5pm.
“Set in the former lamp room of a lighthouse, Longplayer uses the sounds of Tibetan ‘singing bowls’ to take you on a atmospheric journey into time and space.”
You can find out more about Longplayer at longplayer.org. Finer has also written a book detailing its creation. It includes scans of his personal notebooks, meetings of minutes and detailed commentary from inception to creation.