Dead Giveaway

After Closing - Part Two

Listen Later

Episode 11: After Closing (Part Two)

The story didn’t add up.

A locked store.

No forced entry.

In Part One, we walked through a crime scene defined by contradictions. In this conclusion to After Closing, we step away from the fictionalized setting of Red Wing to reveal the disturbing true crime case that inspired this mystery.
Billy breaks down the forensic evidence and crime scene staging that defined one of the most infamous retail murders in history. We’re moving past the witness statements to look at the cold, hard facts that detectives used to uncover what really happened behind those locked doors.
The Investigative Deep-Dive:
  • The 331 Physical Markers: Why the sheer number of injuries changed the entire direction of the case.
  • The Size 14 Impressions: The truth behind the footprints that appeared inside the store but never led outside.
  • A Staged Narrative: How investigators used bloodstain pattern analysis and behavioral cues to dismantle a perfectly crafted lie.
  • The Neighboring Witnesses: What was heard through the walls and why those sounds didn't match the reported story.
    • This episode is a masterclass in investigative psychology, proving that while a witness can lie, the physical evidence is always a Dead Giveaway.

    ~Know someone who loves true crime and a good mystery? Share this episode and see if they can solve it before the reveal.~

    Connect with us

    Billy's New Single

    https://distrokid.com/hyperfollow/billylister/ill-see-you-in-my-dreams-tonight?ref=release

    Instagram

    https://www.instagram.com/deadgiveawaypodcast

    TikTok

    https://www.tiktok.com/@deadgiveawaypodcast

    Support the show

    https://www.patreon.com/cw/DeadGiveawayPodcast

    ABOUT DEAD GIVEAWAY

    The Premise:

    A two-part true crime podcast with a twist.

    Part One:

    Carley presents a fictionalized version of a real case—changing names, locations, and key details. Billy has to solve it before the reveal.

    Part Two – The Reveal:

    We uncover the real case, break down the investigation, and find out whether the truth was hiding in plain sight… or if it was a Dead Giveaway.

    Topics:

    True Crime Mystery, Retail Murder Case, Workplace Crime, Small Town Crime, Suspicious Survivor, Crime Scene Analysis, Investigative Podcast, Unsolved Style Mystery

    ...more
    View all episodesView all episodes
    Download on the App Store
    Dead GiveawayBy Dead Giveaway