AJ heard a crazy softball story from his league but McCall has a criminal story to beat it. Apparently McCall has a stack of stories because bonus Florida Or Not has to do with something AJ wants to try. Does Dustin actually let McCall use power tools? McCall started out the most grossed out because AJ doesn’t think it’s that big a deal to share a toothbrush with his significant other for the Debate At 8, but she comes with the stories to make AJ gag. How did you make it through high school? Someone from Florida has a bone to pick, but do they agree that crazy things are always happening there?