Chase says Utah was right to close the case — Brooke says the most important word in the whole announcement was "consistent." On October 27, 2026, exactly fifty-two years after Melissa Ann Smith was found in Summit County, officials closed her murder and named Ted Bundy, based on a Y-STR profile developed from Laura Ann Aime's case plus pattern, motive, means and opportunity. Chase and Brooke fight over what that science proves — and what it cannot.