March 08, 2025

Americans in Mexico and Canada

Cross-Border Financial Planning: What Americans Moving to Canada and Mexico Need to Know

As a U.S. citizen living in or planning to move to Canada or Mexico, navigating the complexities of cross-border financial planning is crucial. From tax obligations to investment strategies and estate planning, understanding how to manage your finances effectively across borders can save you time, money, and stress. At AIO Financial, we specialize in helping Americans living abroad, ensuring that their financial strategies align with their long-term goals and legal requirements.

Why Americans Choose to Live in Canada or Mexico

Many Americans choose to relocate to Canada or Mexico for a variety of reasons, including:

Healthcare: Canada offers universal healthcare, while Mexico has affordable private healthcare options.

Cost of Living: Mexico, in particular, has a lower cost of living compared to many parts of the U.S.

Weather: Warmer climates in Mexico attract retirees, while Canada’s seasons appeal to those who enjoy diverse weather.

Culture & Lifestyle: Expats appreciate the rich cultures, cuisines, and traditions of both countries.

Adventure & Outdoors: Whether it’s hiking in the Canadian Rockies or enjoying Mexico’s beaches, both nations offer incredible outdoor experiences.

Work & Business Opportunities: Some move for career opportunities, while others work remotely or start businesses abroad.

Romance & Family: Many Americans relocate for relationships or to be closer to family members who have already made the move.

Personal Growth & Change: Moving abroad is a chance for a fresh start, new experiences, and personal development.

Tax Considerations for U.S. Expats in Canada and Mexico

One of the biggest financial challenges for Americans abroad is taxation. The U.S. taxes its citizens on worldwide income, meaning you must file a U.S. tax return even if you reside in Canada or Mexico.

Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (FEIE): If you qualify under the Physical Presence or Bona Fide Residence tests, you may exclude up to $120,000 (as of 2023) of earned income from U.S. taxation.

Foreign Tax Credits (FTC): If you pay taxes in Canada or Mexico, you can often use the FTC to avoid double taxation.

Tax Treaties: The U.S. has tax treaties with both Canada and Mexico to help prevent double taxation and determine tax treatment for different types of income.

FBAR and FATCA Reporting: If you have foreign bank accounts exceeding $10,000, you must file an FBAR (Foreign Bank Account Report). Additionally, the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) requires reporting of foreign financial assets over specific thresholds.

State Tax Considerations: Some U.S. states (such as California and New York) may still require you to file state tax returns even if you live abroad, depending on your residency status.

Choosing a U.S. State of Residence:

Some states do not have a state income tax, making them favorable choices for expats: Alaska, Florida, Nevada, New Hampshire (No tax on earned income, but it taxes interest and dividends), South Dakota, Tennessee (Fully eliminated its tax on interest and dividends in 2021), Texas, Washington (No tax on earned income, but has a capital gains tax on high earners), Wyoming.

If you are still considered a resident of a state with high taxes (such as California or New York), you may need to prove you have severed ties to avoid state taxation.

Steps to change your state of residency include updating your U.S. address to a no-tax state, closing accounts tied to your previous state, obtaining a driver’s license in the new state, and ensuring tax filings reflect your new residency.

Certain states make it difficult to sever residency, so careful planning is necessary.

Each country has unique tax treaties with the U.S., so consulting a financial planner familiar with cross-border tax laws is essential.

Additional Tax Considerations

Roth Accounts & Tax Treatment:

Canada recognizes Roth IRAs under its tax treaty with the U.S., meaning distributions are generally tax-free in both countries.

Mexico does not provide the same recognition, and Roth withdrawals could be subject to taxation there.

Capital Gains Taxes:

The U.S. applies capital gains tax based on how long you have held an asset. Long-term capital gains (held over a year) are taxed at lower rates (0%, 15%, or 20%).

Canada taxes capital gains at 50% of the gain added to your income.

Mexico taxes capital gains on real estate and investments at varied rates, depending on residency status and asset type.

Comparing Tax Brackets (2023 Data):

S.: The highest tax bracket is 37%.

Canada: The highest tax bracket can exceed 50%, depending on the province.

Mexico: The highest income tax bracket is around 35%.

Depending on your income level, you may pay more or less tax abroad, so tax planning is essential.

Residency Visas and Path to Citizenship

If you’re considering moving to Canada or Mexico long-term, understanding residency and citizenship pathways is crucial.

Mexico Residency & Citizenship

Temporary Resident Visa:

Designed for those staying longer than six months but less than four years.

Requires proof of financial stability (e.g., monthly income of around $2,500+ or substantial savings).

Permanent Resident Visa:

After holding a temporary visa for four years, you may apply for permanent residency.

Immediate permanent residency is possible for retirees meeting financial requirements.

Path to Citizenship:

After five years of residency, you may apply for Mexican citizenship.

Requires passing a Spanish language test and a basic Mexican history/culture exam.

Canada Residency & Citizenship

Express Entry (For Skilled Workers):

Points-based system prioritizing skills, education, and work experience.

Requires job offers, high language proficiency, and proof of financial self-sufficiency.

Family Sponsorship:

Available if you have a Canadian spouse, parent, or child who can sponsor you.

Provincial Nominee Program (PNP):

Some provinces offer expedited residency for individuals with specific skills.

Path to Citizenship:

After three years of permanent residency, you may apply for Canadian citizenship.

Requires passing a citizenship test and proving language proficiency.

Investment Strategies for U.S. Expats

Investing while living in Canada or Mexico presents additional challenges due to tax and regulatory implications.

U.S. vs. Local Investment Accounts

Maintaining a U.S. Investment Account: Many Americans living in Mexico or Canada prefer to maintain their U.S. investment accounts to simplify tax reporting and avoid foreign investment restrictions. For example:

Mexico: Americans residing in Mexico can open and maintain a Schwab account, which allows them to invest in U.S. markets while avoiding certain foreign investment complications.

Canada: Some U.S. brokerage firms, such as Schwab and Interactive Brokers, allow Americans living in Canada to maintain accounts, but many major firms (such as Vanguard and Fidelity) restrict services for non-U.S. residents. Working with a brokerage that supports expats is crucial.

Banking Restrictions: Some U.S. banks and brokerage firms may limit access or require additional documentation for Americans living abroad.

Local Investment Accounts:

Canada: Many Canadian financial institutions do not allow U.S. citizens to open investment accounts due to FATCA compliance and IRS reporting requirements.

Mexico: Investing in Mexican mutual funds or other investment vehicles may trigger PFIC (Passive Foreign Investment Company) tax rules, which can result in unfavorable taxation when filing U.S. taxes.

Foreign Currency Exposure: Investing in local markets means dealing with currency fluctuations, which can impact your returns. Consider currency-hedged investments or holding assets in both U.S. dollars and local currency.

U.S. Retirement Accounts:

IRAs and 401(k)s: Expats can maintain their U.S.-based retirement accounts, but withdrawals may be taxed in both the U.S. and their country of residence.

Tax Treaties & Roth IRAs: Canada recognizes Roth IRAs under its tax treaty with the U.S., meaning distributions are generally tax-free in both countries. However, Mexico does not provide the same recognition, and Roth withdrawals could be subject to taxation there.

Employer Retirement Plans: If you work in Canada or Mexico, you may have access to local retirement plans (such as the RRSP in Canada or the Afore in Mexico), but contributions may not always be tax-deductible for U.S. tax purposes.

Retirement Planning and Social Security

If you plan to retire in Canada or Mexico, understanding how U.S. Social Security benefits integrate with local retirement systems is key.

Totalization Agreements: The U.S. has agreements with Canada and Mexico to prevent double taxation of Social Security benefits and to coordinate retirement benefits.

Social Security Benefits in Canada and Mexico:

You can receive U.S. Social Security payments while living in either country.

Canada provides additional pension options such as CPP and OAS, which can supplement Social Security benefits.

Mexico does not have an extensive government pension program, so expats often rely on personal savings and investment accounts.

Medicare Considerations: Medicare generally does not cover medical expenses outside the U.S., so securing local health insurance is important.

Long-Term Care Planning: If you plan to stay in Canada or Mexico long-term, consider how you’ll fund potential long-term care expenses.

Estate Planning for Americans Abroad

Estate planning becomes more complex when assets are held in multiple countries.

Wills and Trusts: A U.S. will may not be recognized in Canada or Mexico, so having separate estate documents aligned with local laws is recommended.

Tax Implications: U.S. citizens are subject to U.S. estate tax on worldwide assets, while Canada and Mexico have different inheritance laws and taxation structures.

Beneficiary Designations: Ensuring your accounts have updated beneficiary designations can prevent probate complications across borders.

Property Ownership: If you own real estate in Canada or Mexico, review local inheritance laws, as some restrictions may apply to foreign heirs.

Power of Attorney: It may be beneficial to have a power of attorney both in the U.S. and in your country of residence to facilitate financial and healthcare decisions if needed.

Work with a Fee-Only Fiduciary Financial Planner

Managing finances across borders is complex, and working with a financial planner who understands U.S. tax laws, international investments, and cross-border retirement planning is essential. At AIO Financial, we are fee-only fiduciary financial advisors specializing in Socially Responsible Investing (SRI) and helping U.S. citizens navigate financial life in Canada and Mexico.

Whether you’re moving, investing, or planning for retirement abroad, we can help you create a financial strategy that optimizes your wealth and ensures compliance with international tax and legal requirements.

Schedule a Consultation Today

If you’re an American living in or planning to move to Canada or Mexico, contact us for a personalized financial strategy tailored to your needs. Let’s ensure your financial future is secure, wherever you call home.

https://go.oncehub.com/aioconsultation

Transcript of Video

I’m gonna go over financial planning
for Americans who wanna live in Canada
or Mexico or who are already there
my name is Bill Holiday I’m with AIO Financial
we’re gonna cover taxes the visa
residency issues and some other financial issues
so why would anyone want to move to Canada or Mexico
or spend part of the year in Canada or Mexico
one is weather cost a living
healthcare considerations for sure
healthcare system in the US is expensive
I haven’t had the best experience with it
just culture different lifestyle
some outdoor adventures
maybe it’s work or business or education
it could be romance
or family that are pulling you to Mexico or Canada
it could just be you wanna change
and it’s not too far from the US for sure
tax considerations taxes are pretty big
US is tax and worldwide income
so you’re gonna be filing US taxes no matter what
there is a foreign exclusion
so up to all in 2025 up to 130,000 is not double taxed
so you’ll pay it just once
you do get a credit
that just goes along with the no double taxing
and aspire if you have a foreign account Canada
Mexico or any other country
you have a foreign bank account
or foreign investment account
with more than $10,000 in it
at any point during the year
you just need to let the US government know
FBI is just a filing with your taxes saying
here’s the max I had and there’s not tax on it
they just wanna know
where your foreign assets are located
and then definitely consider your state taxes
so there are 3 4 5
6 7
8 9 states with no state income tax
if you do have a connection to a state
you’re keeping a house you’re only partially moving
then you’re gonna be filing state taxes
if you don’t have much of a connection
you could either not declare any state
or pick a state with 9 or low state taxes
you might wanna
sever your ties with a high income tax state
and then to change states
you just wanna update your address
your driver’s license
any other license and your tax filings
and then you’ll be dealing with that state
Roth accounts are tax free
when you’re pulling money out of a Roth in Canada
and they say tax in Mexico
we haven’t had that issue come up
but they are taxed in Spain
I know some states you pay taxes on Roth account
money that’s coming out
same as with an IRA just counts as income
I’ll leave that there
capital gains taxes are taxes
differently in the other states
again you’re not double taxed but
you’re paying the highest
you’ll pay up to that limit of the US tax
and then if it’s higher in your situation
in Canada or Mexico
then you’ll be paying that difference
Canada’s tax brackets are a bit higher
a lot of people do just go using a tourist visa
not spending the whole time
not actually converting to citizens
but some do the pros and cons
and then we do have Mexicans looking at being in Canada
as well there’s frozen cats
investments generally
we recommend keeping your investment accounts in the US
they have good transparency security
low expenses big variety of investments
haven’t heard a good argument
for keeping investment accounts
outside of the US but local banking
that can make sense to have in the country
you’re moving to
just for convenience
you can transfer assets or transfer funds as needed
and having a local bank can be helpful
Social Security you’re not getting the double taxation
we already talked about that
you can receive Social Security
it’ll go in your bank account
you can move funds abroad
Medicare is not gonna cover you
for Mexican or Canadian doctors
but you can come back and use it
long term care planning
you just wanna think about that
that can be a lot more reasonable outside the US
it’s very expensive in the US stay planning
if you are permanently living
or spending a good amount of time in another country
powers of attorney living wells
that can make sense to have
in the country where you’re living
make sure your beneficiaries are up to date
if you have real estate
you wanna make sure there’s beneficiaries on that
where you are in Mexico
I know you could put beneficiaries on real estate
just wanna make sure if something episode 1 or 2 people
the spouse or or just yourself that you’re covered
assets will pass as you’d want
with his little hassle and
little taxes as possible
there are some rules around property ownership
that to be considered
Mexico does have some limitations towards the coast
as far as Mexico goes
it’s a pretty straightforward process
if you can prove that you’re meeting the finance
financial requirements of assets and income
you’re fine to get a temporary residency
after four years
it converts to a permanent resident visa
you don’t need to go any further
but a five years of residency
you can apply for citizenship
and there’s a language and history test
the history test is kind of a pain
but if you’re 60 years old or over
you can bypass that history test so it can be good
then you can vote you’re a citizen it can be helpful
in Canada again
tourist visas up for six months is for six months
and that’s the easiest way
you’re not in their healthcare system
but you can get private health care insurance
and cover you while you’re there
if you are trying to
even a virtual nomad working while you’re there
there’s a point system language
age education um
that all count towards these points
of whether they’re gonna accept you or not
if you have family course
that’ll help with three years of permanent residency
you can apply for citizenship
there is a language and citizenship test
so several options all right
AAU Financial were fee only advisers
we don’t get any commissions
we don’t sell any products
we do work with a lot of expats in Canada
Mexico a lot in Mexico and then Europe
cross border retirement planning
we do have a lot of clients interested in sustainable
responsible impact investing
feel free to reach out AIO Financial
com you could set up a free meeting
we’ll go over your needs and our services
and how we work
let me know if you have any questions or comments
let me know I’d appreciate it
alright thanks a lot
take care bye

The post Americans in Mexico and Canada appeared first on AIO Financial - Fee Only Financial Advisors.

...more

View all episodes

Values Investors Podcast | Socially Responsible Investing, ESG, Ethical, Impact, Sustainable Investments

By Bill Holliday, CFP