When the Lutz family purchased their dream home in Amityville, they thought they won the lottery. There may have been a brutal murder in the home the year before, but it was nothing that their parish priest couldn't bless away... or was it?

They lasted 28 days in the house on Ocean Avenue before fleeing with barely more than the clothes on their backs. The Lutz family went to the media with their story and started a phenomenon that nobody could have predicted.

Were they victims of a demonic presence or opportunists looking to cash in on a tragedy? Who knows...

We were so conflicted we forgot to give this story a grade!

Check out our resources at obviouslyhaunted.com.