Matthew said he was willing to eat his words on One Piece. Consider them eaten.

After finally watching the Netflix live action, and immediately looking at his girlfriend and going "next episode", Matthew brings his full list of questions, hot takes, and genuine emotional reactions to Jacob and returning guest Robbie (BlindCraziness), two of the biggest One Piece fans in the room.

They break down why the live action actually works (spoiler: Oda had a stranglehold on every casting decision and every scene), which actors fully become their characters and why, the philosophy behind Luffy as a main character, and why One Piece might be a story that was never meant for you as a kid. Also: the Kuina stairs meme, Mihawk's absolute big dick energy, Zoro's 100-man fight with a broken finger, and the one scene Jacob bawled his eyes out to.

OUR DISCORD IS LIVE!!! 

WE GOT AN ALBUM ON Apple Music & Spotify NOW!!!

Subscribe to our Youtube @TalkingTrubbish

Email us your stories or questions!

[email protected]

00:00 Welcome back -- Robbie returns, Matthew has news

01:47 Matthew watched the One Piece live action and immediately got hooked

04:15 Oda's creative control over the live action, every casting decision, every scene

08:06 Breaking down the cast -- Sanji's actor, the YouTube channel, his obsessive prep for the Baratie fight

12:17 Usopp's actor versus anime Usopp, Zoro's 100-man fight and the broken finger

15:01 Matthew digs into the One Piece mystery -- Gold Roger, what "One Piece" actually means, and how the name was born

23:21 Why One Piece didn't land as a kid but hits different as an adult -- the Shanks scene, emotional intelligence, and the show's real tone

30:16 How the story and Oda himself have matured over 25+ years -- stakes, socioeconomics, Luffy's design philosophy

34:36 Luffy's no-thought-bubble rule, Kuina's death (the meme), Zoro's backstory, and Matthew's plot device theory

41:51 Mihawk fandom, favorite characters -- Jacob picks Zoro, Robbie teases the final Straw Hat crew member

47:53 Luffy vs. Goku vs. Naruto -- the goofy-but-dangerous main character comparison, Robbie's "I Get Knocked Down" Luffy theory

51:56 Garp's early reveal, the art style struggle, and Matthew commits to reading the manga

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.