For More Events on This Day in Scottish History - https://bagtownclans.com/index.php/thisday/april-19/

Welcome back to This Day in Scottish History. I'm your host, Colin MacDonald. Today, we're diving deep into the cold, murky waters of Loch Ness—not to swim, but to resurface one of the most enduring hoaxes in cryptozoological history. It was on this day, April 19th, 1934, that the world first heard of a certain London surgeon named Robert Kenneth Wilson, who claimed to have captured a photograph of a mysterious creature surfacing from the legendary loch. That image—grainy, black and white, and profoundly eerie—would become the most famous photo ever taken of the so-called Loch Ness Monster. But as we’ll discover, not all is as it seems when it comes to monsters and men.

It all started with an innocuous shooting trip near Inverness. Dr. Wilson, a respected gynecologist, claimed he was enjoying the scenic beauty of the Highlands when he noticed a disturbance in the waters of Loch Ness. Out came his camera, and what he captured would soon send shockwaves across the world. The photo he submitted to the Daily Mail just two days later showed what looked like a long neck and small head rising out of the loch. A serpentine figure, dark and mysterious, appeared to cruise through the rippling waters like something from the age of dinosaurs.

The Daily Mail ran the image on April 21st, and the public went wild. Here was the proof! The Loch Ness Monster was real. No longer just the stuff of whispered stories or shadowy local legends, Nessie had a face—well, sort of. The photo was immediately dubbed the “Surgeon’s Photograph,” after Dr. Wilson himself, who claimed he didn’t want his name associated with it and preferred to remain anonymous. It only added to the intrigue. Who was this quiet, respectable doctor who had caught a glimpse of the beast?

For sixty years, the photo stood virtually unchallenged. Scientists studied it, skeptics dissected it, and believers revered it. It was featured in books, magazines, and documentaries, feeding a growing industry of Nessie tourism and legend. Expeditions were launched. Sonar equipment scanned the loch’s depths. And yet, no clearer photo ever surfaced. But that didn’t matter. The Surgeon’s Photograph was enough. For generations, it was the holy grail of monster hunting.

But as with all great legends, truth eventually caught up to fiction. In 1994—exactly sixty years after the photo was taken—the hoax was finally exposed. And the story behind it was every bit as bizarre and theatrical as the photo itself.

Enter Marmaduke Wetherell, a flamboyant big-game hunter hired by the Daily Mail in the early 1930s to find proof of the Loch Ness Monster. Wetherell claimed he had discovered Nessie’s footprints on the shores of the loch, only to be thoroughly embarrassed when zoologists revealed the prints were made with a dried hippopotamus foot—probably the base of an umbrella stand.

Humiliated and furious, Wetherell plotted his revenge. With the help of his son Ian and stepson Christian Spurling—an expert model maker—they constructed a model of Nessie’s head and neck, about a foot long, and mounted it on a toy submarine. They launched it into the loch and took several photos before sinking the model. But they needed someone respectable to present the photo to the press, someone whose name would lend credibility to the image.

That man was Dr. Robert Kenneth Wilson. A friend of Wetherell’s, he agreed to play along and submitted the photo to the Daily Mail, claiming he’d taken it during a nature walk. The ruse worked better than any of them could have imagined. The photo went global, and no one suspected a thing—until Spurling, then in his nineties, finally confessed on his deathbed. The photo was a hoax, and Nessie, at least in this instance, was a twelve-inch toy on a child’s submarine.

But even now, knowing the truth, the image endures. There’s something compelling about the idea of a hidden creature in the depths of a Scottish loch. Perhaps it speaks to our longing for mystery, for the unknown, for the possibility that some legends might still be real. The Surgeon’s Photograph may have been a fake, but the fascination it inspired was very real—and continues to this day.

Thank you for joining me today on This Day in Scottish History. I hope you’ve enjoyed this journey into hoaxes, legends, and the curious depths of human imagination. And don’t forget to check out my blog for more tales from Scotland’s rich past at bagtownclans.com/thisday. Until next time, I’m Colin MacDonald—Haste Ye Back!

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bagtown.substack.com