Packed with everything from color-changing nail polish to stick-on starfish earrings, Aquamarine (2006) is every girl’s mermaid fantasy brought to life. This week, we do our best to see if there’s anything beneath the glittery surface of this 2000s teen classic, or if it’s as shallow as the waves that brought in Aquamarine herself.

Please rate and review! Say hi on Instagram and Tumblr, email us at [email protected], and visit our website for more.