On November 7, 1983, a tragic crime occurred in Bloomington, Illinois, involving the seemingly perfect Hendricks family. David Hendricks, a successful businessman and devoutly religious man, left his home around midnight for a business trip to Wisconsin. The following day, after failing to reach his wife by phone, he asked a neighbor and eventually the police to check his house.Responding officers discovered David's 30-year-old wife, Susan, and their three children deceased in their beds. The attacker had used an axe and a large bread knife, both of which belonged to the family. These weapons were left in plain sight next to the victims and had been meticulously wiped clean of any fingerprints or DNA. Despite the severe nature of the injuries, the perpetrator managed to keep the rest of the house completely spotless, leaving no blood, DNA, or distinct footprints downstairs. The crime scene appeared to be staged as a burglary, with drawers pulled out and furniture moved, yet nothing valuable was actually stolen.Investigators quickly focused on David as the primary suspect, largely due to his notably calm and emotionless reaction to the news of his family's death. The prosecution's case relied heavily on circumstantial evidence, particularly the stomach contents of the children. Because the children had eaten pizza earlier that evening, a medical examiner used the undigested food to estimate the time of death between 9:00 PM and 10:00 PM, a window during which David was still at home. Additionally, prosecutors argued David had a motive to start a new life free from his strict religious marriage, pointing to his recent physical makeover, weight loss, and alleged flirtations with models he hired for his orthopedic supply business. In 1984, David was convicted and sentenced to life in prison.However, the defense argued that there was no physical evidence connecting David to the murders, noting the complete absence of blood or DNA in his car, on his clothes, or under his fingernails. In 1991, David's conviction was overturned and he was acquitted, largely because the court determined that stomach contents were an unreliable scientific method for accurately establishing the time of death.Another potential suspect emerged in the case: John Lewis, the ex-husband of Susan's sister. After their divorce, his ex-wife claimed that on the night of the murders, he had left the house to lift weights and later returned home with a blood-stained medical apron, asking her to wash it. John had also previously made a disturbing comment to the youngest Hendricks child during a walk through a cemetery, asking if the five-year-old boy was "ready for death". Despite these claims, John passed a polygraph test, and the horrific crime remains officially unsolved.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support.