Becky Albertalli is known for hilarious, feelsy, sweet and sour high school stories stuffed with wildly relatable insights and characters that will become your best friends. Adam Silvera is known for searching, often speculative tales of first love, painful memories, and coming of age that want to rip your heart out and use it as a book jacket. So ever since the two announced that they were collaborating on a meet-cute love story, fans have been debating whether we should prepare ourselves for happy tears or miserable tears. No spoilers here, but we did talk to Becky and Adam about their fandoms, their high school selves, and What If It’s Us, their ridiculously adorable book.