Only the diehards believed and even some of them might admit it was only half-heartedly. NYCFC limped into Subaru Park on Sunday night and took the fight to the Supporter's Shield owners leaving them with only their dreams of hoisting a cup.

This week Mike Anderer, J.R. diBart and Mike Allen recap the moments from this Eastern Conference semi-final that made it so special. They also look ahead at the difficult task of taking down Lionel Messi and Inter Miami FC on Saturday.

NYCFC is a team that knows how to handle adversity. Their legacy began with the club's second biggest signing missing the first half of their debut season. Their championship season was marked with two key season-ending injuries. Last year breakout rookie star, Malachi Jones, suffered a severe injury mid-season that he still has yet to return from. Despite all of these moments, the team rises, the team comes together and the bond grows.

Friday night was another of those moments as midfielder Andres Perea would land awkwardly breaking both his tibia and fibula in the 70th minute in Charlotte.

The Boys In Blue rallied as they often do to hold off the home side and win the deciding game 3-1.

This week Mike Anderer, J.R. diBart and Mike Allen discuss the options Pascal Jansen has to build a midfield for the next match in Chester, PA. They also look back at the key moments from game three of the first round series.

NYCFC had a golden opportunity to defeat the team ahead of them in the standings and advance to the second round of the MLS Cup Playoffs. Unfortunately the result did not go their way and while it is easy to blame the two young players that missed their penalty kick chances the coach was more focused on why it was not decided in regulation. That leadership is what hopefully will give NYCFC the advantage they need on Friday night in Charlotte.

This week Mike Anderer, Mike Allen and J.R. diBart discuss the idea of supporting players during the toughest moments. They also talk more about David Lee's departure and look back at the first two games of the playoff series.

There is audio from Pascal Jansen, Hannes Wolf, Matt Freese, Justin Haak and Tayvon Gray.

Yes, NYCFC lost to Seattle at home on decision day. Yes, Mike, J.R. and Mike will discuss it, but before they do, they need to share their thoughts on the state of journalism and coverage of MLS by independent reporters.

It was always a challenge and with the passing of time, it has only gotten worse. The big question is will it ever turn around?

This is part two of our series talking with fans and friends from the first ten years of NYCFC history.

This episode focuses on two questions: what do you want to see in the NYCFC stadium? and where would you be without NYCFC?

A new NYCFC era is upon us. We now enter the Post-David-Lee era as the former sporting director departs for the vacant position in Kansas City. As NYCFC wrap up the 2025 season the team will do so trying to fill the key role and look to develop a roster ready to open their stadium in 2027.

This week Mike, J.R. and Mike discuss the tenure of David Lee and his legacy of player signings. They also look back on the loss to Philadelphia Union in Chester.

How do you feel as an NYCFC fan after the week they had? They were embarrassed at home against one of the strongest teams in the league and then fought back valiantly against their cross-river rival to capture the Hudson River Trophy.

It is really a tale of opposites, but ultimately the spirits are running high as they enter the last two weeks of the season.

And to add some more sugar to the coffee, members of the media, including Blue City Radio's own JR diBart, were given their first tour of Ethiad Park. That's a lot to talk about but the guys get it done and all in less than 90 minutes.

There was so much going on with NYCFC last week that we did not think we could fit all of our thoughts into one episode, and we didn't. The guys did share some audio with NYCFC CEO, Brad Sims, as well as recap the two thrilling wins from the week that give the Boys In Blue great momentum heading into another extremely challenging week.

For weeks we have been waiting for some consistency from NYCFC. Too often their victories fooled pundits and fans alike into thinking they were a solid squad worthy of making a playoff run, only to be followed by games that made people quip if they would make the playoffs at all.

Obviously one game is not enough to sway opinions, but with the remaining six games approaching the victory in Chicago was a great start.

Listen this week as the guys breakdown the Fire victory and look ahead at the games that remain. There is also audio from Seymour Reid, Pascal Jansen and Nico Fernandez Mercau.

As we watch NYCFC play it's eleventh season in MLS we thought it would be a perfect time to capture some memories of the first ten years. During the beginning of this season Mike Anderer sat down with some notable fans and friends to hear their stories about the growth of the team. Featured in these episodes are Jon Sanchez, Andy Bajana, Trey Fillmore, Christian Polanco, Chelsea Socias, Gretta Fernandez, Deron Jenkins, Danny Chediak, Brenda Picinic and Karol Lamb.