We bring back our chaotic Top 5 segment — and this time, we’re digging through the most haunted objects ever sold on eBay. From cursed wedding rings and whispering teddy bears to journals that seem to write themselves, each reveal somehow gets worse than the last. The competition heats up, the reactions get louder, and by the time we hit the number one spot, we’re questioning why anyone would ever click “Buy It Now” again, but we're also questioning ourselves on why we both got the answer wrong. Tune in to find out what #1 was!

Got a story to tell us? Email us at [email protected]