We're taking a break from our friends at the Dam to get to the next wild chapter of 2008's New Amsterdam:  the short-lived procedural about an immortal homicide detective searching for his soulmate, all while struggling to fake an American accent. In this episode, a star pupil at a local college is found strangled, and we have some shocking revelations about John Amsterdam's past lover(s). 

Polly is always forced to wear vests on stage, and Emily still loses her mind over Adele Dazeem in the year 2021.