A quintessential millennium era horror title has been revived as a series, and Sam and Jordan have decided they have no choice but to cover it. I Know What You Did Last Summer is now streaming on Prime, and it's ignoring your nostalgia while screaming, "We are modern teens!" This show is a mess, but it's the kind of mess your co-hosts love, and it's also got hot queer characters making big impressions from the jump. Will this show turn supernatural? Is it a shadow sequel to Pretty Little Liars? Will we be mercifully freed from the character of Dylan, or must we suffer him throughout the entire season? Let the speculation and analysis begin.

Produced by: Jordan Crucchiola

Music by: Sam Wineman