Polly and Emily take a quick break from their favorite medical drama to finally watch the pilot for the other New Amsterdam: Fox's short-lived police procedural from 2008.

In episode 1 (of 8) we meet Detecitve John Amsterdam, the brooding homicide detective with a rare Native American blood type, cursed to live forever until he finds his true love. Emily achieves peak Brooklyn by sitting in her closet, and Polly shares some wild and wacky Death Cab for Cutie trivia.