In 2026 three podcasters attempted to record an episode of their beloved horror movie show. But, unbeknownst to Chris and Kyle, [redacted] mysteriously disappeared 13 minutes into the recording. For months this episode was thought to be lost, until investigators found it in Superfan Ben’s dirty basement. This episode contains uncomfortably long pauses where [redacted] once spoke. Investigators have attempted to edit down those pauses as much as possible in an effort to learn what happened to the Boo Boys. 

What goes bump in the night giving Kyle a fright? This week it’s Milk & Serial (2024) directed by Curry Barker in his debut. This film has a pair of YouTubers get in over their heads after a prank goes wrong. What would make a great YouTube movie? Can Kyle rehabilitate creepy vans? Can anyone hear Mat? Get yourself a bowl of cereal as the Boo Boys break it all down. 

What goes bump in the night giving Kyle a fright? This week it’s Found Footage: The Making of the Patterson Project (2025) directed by Max Tzannes. This horror comedy follows an ill-fated film crew as they attempt to make a movie about Bigfoot. What does MREs stand for? How much did Kyle laugh? Can the boys find proof about Bigfoot? Don’t get stuck in a paradox as the Boo Boys break it all down. 

What goes bump in the night giving Chris and Mat a fright? This week it’s Good Boy (2025) directed by Ben Leonberg, as another bonus episode with special guest Ben. This haunted house film is told through the perspective of a dog. Was this pup really a good boy? How much money did Ben get after stealing a neighborhood dog? What is Chris’ favorite meal while racing the Iditarod? Don’t let the dogs out as the Boo Boys break it all down.

What goes bump in the night giving Kyle a fright? This week it’s The Borderlands aka Final Prayer (2013) directed by Elliot Goldner. This British film has a team investigating the validity of a miracle. Is Deacon Deacon the ultimate Deacon? How can we invest in Google Mat? Is there anything spookier than a cup falling over? Sing along to Kyle’s hymn as the Boo Boys break it all down. 

What goes bump in the night giving Kyle a fright? This week it’s Paranormal Activity 3 (2011) directed by Henry Joost and Ariel Schulman. This prequel haunted house film shows how an ill-fated pair of sisters got wrapped up in a demon’s machinations. What was it like going on a date with high school Kyle? How do you play Bloody Mary? What is Mat’s plan for future imaginary friends? Scrub through those hours of footage as the Boo Boys break it all down. 

What goes bump in the night giving Kyle a fright? This week it’s Troll Hunter (2010) directed by André Øvredal. This fantasy film has a documentary team follow a troll hunter as he investigates a series of sightings across Norway. What scent is powerful enough to hide Kyle’s love of Jesus? Can AI figure out how scary a film is? Why can’t we get anatomically correct trolls? Buy your tickets for Troll Hunter Generations as the Boo Boys break it all down. 

What goes bump in the night giving Kyle a fright? This week for the Season 13 premier its The Taking of Deborah Logan (2014) directed by Adam Robitel. This found footage film has a documentary crew capture the unravelling of an Alzheimer’s patient with snake-like tendencies. How did Mat become unstuck in time. Can you be an ethical documentarian? Would you rather buy a raptor or mongoose? Unhinge your jaw as the Boo Boys break it all down. 

What goes bump in the night giving Kyle a fright? This week for the Season 12 finale its Send Help (2026) directed by Sam Raimi. This film has a pair of corporate folks face survival challenges after getting stranded on an island. Are the boys Team Rachel or Team Dylan? Why is Kyle signing a DNR? What can Mat tell us about Survivor 50? Munch on that Feastable as the Boo Boys break it all down. 

Where’s my Kyle? Where’s my Boo Boy? I’ll tear this whole podcast apart with my bare hands. This week special guest Dane joins Chris and Mat for Killer Klowns from Outer Space (1988) directed by the Chiodo Brothers. This horror comedy has spooky clowns terrorize a town. What is the best circus food? How did this film awaken young Dane? Is Mat a circus freak? Pop that balloon as the Boo Boys break it all down.