Hour 1

Boomer and guest host Sal Licata kicked off their show discussing the Knicks' dramatic win over Portland, highlighting Mikal Bridges' concerns about excessive playing time and a potential discrepancy with Coach Thibs' account of their conversation. Sal shared his enthusiasm for his recent move to New Jersey, contrasting it with his Long Island roots, and then fielded questions about Giants fans' opinions on Aaron Rodgers. The conversation shifted to the Giants' draft strategy and potential picks, followed by C-Lo's recap of the Knicks' buzzer-beater. A caller's critique of Sal's volume prompted a lighthearted exchange, and the hour concluded with analysis of the Jets' quarterback situation, focusing on Justin Fields' accuracy, and the Giants' ongoing pursuit of quarterbacks like Rodgers and Russell Wilson.

Hour 2

Boomer and guest host Sal Licata explored Sal's adjustment to filling in, questioning Boomer's off-air friendship with Gio and debating Kevin James's Mets fandom. They discussed the Yankees' decision to avoid Trevor Bauer, with both agreeing his time had passed. Sal wondered if Boomer could excel in the modern NFL. C-Lo's update followed, prefaced by a discussion of the competitive NFC East and Boomer's hypothetical choice of Pittsburgh for Aaron Rodgers. The Knicks' win and Rodgers' delayed decision, which angered Adam Schefter, were covered, with Sal defending Rodgers' right to take his time. The hour concluded with a discussion of West Virginia's coach banning TikTok dancing, a caller's belief in Boomer's NFL dominance, and Boomer's enjoyment of avocado ice cream.

Hour 3

Boomer began with a sports minute about a prolific golf ball retriever, then discussed the replanted, controversial tree at TPC Sawgrass. Sal shared his own tree-related neighbor dispute, which led to a discussion of Boomer's fence experience and similar caller stories. C-Lo's update was prefaced by Boomer's observation of Aly's parking skills, followed by Adam Schefter's commentary on Aaron Rodgers' prolonged free agency, with the Steelers, Giants, and Vikings still in contention. A surprising revelation of Sal and Al's shared romantic history added a personal touch, and the hour concluded with speculation on the impact of Aaron Rodgers potentially joining the Giants.

Hour 4

Brandon Tierney joined to discuss St. John's basketball, analyzing their Big East Tournament and NCAA Tournament prospects. C-Lo's final update included Rangers' season woes, a lengthy hockey discussion, the Knicks' dramatic win, and Jerry Recco's call of Rutgers' double-overtime loss. Rory McIlroy's views on YouTube golf were mentioned, and Boomer's pronunciation struggle with "pre-fix" became the Moment of the Day. The show concluded with talk of Pete Alonso's strong Mets lineup and a ranking of local professional sports general managers.