Hour 1

Boomer and Jerry, filling in for Gio, kicked off the show discussing Tracy Morgan's courtside incident at the Knicks game, where he was seen leaving in a wheelchair after vomiting. They acknowledged the Knicks' win over the Heat, highlighting Miami's poor defense, while Boomer expressed concerns about the Knicks' playoff defense. The conversation shifted to the Jets, emphasizing the need for organizational changes and a clear franchise leader. C-Lo's update featured Knicks victory sounds and Jameis Winston's Giants meeting, with a humorous aside about Anthony Gallo's odor. The hour concluded with Jerry gifting Boomer a hoodie and a caller questioning Boomer's interest in joining the Jets if he was still playing.

Hour 2

The show debated the Steelers' quarterback choices, questioning if passing on Russell Wilson and Justin Fields was a red flag. The conversation then shifted to Aaron Rodgers' potential move to Minnesota and the quarterback options for the Jets, including a jokingly mentioned Carson Wentz. Updates included Jameis Winston's Giants visit, Russell Wilson's earlier visit, and Joe Flacco's continued availability. C-Lo's update featured Knicks victory sounds and the Rangers' honoring of Sam Rosen. The Tracy Morgan incident at the Knicks game was revisited, followed by clips of Al from the Warm Up Show. The hour concluded with Boomer discussing the NCAA tournament and North Carolina's controversy, and Jerry quizzing Al on St. John's players.

Hour 3

The show opened with the astronauts' return, followed a discussion about Al Dukes' lack of sports knowledge. MLB and MVP odds surprised Jerry, leading to a contentious debate over Gerrit Cole's World Series first base coverage, sparking numerous caller disagreements. C-Lo's update featured a heated exchange between Tiki Barber and a caller. The hour concluded with further calls dissecting the Gerrit Cole first base controversy.

Hour 4

The show discussed NFL draft quarterbacks, the Giants' quarterback situation, and the Knicks' win over the Heat. Colin Cowherd is tired of Rodgers' indecision, and the Governor of West Virginia wants to investigate the NCAA's bracket selection. The Moment of the Day featured Al's hot NFL takes, and WNBA player Cameron Brink is concerned about the Sparks' practice plans.