Hour 1

Gio stirred controversy by calling Karl-Anthony Towns a "loser" in reference to his playoff performance with the Knicks, drawing criticism from Carl Banks, whom Gio dismissed as poor in media. The discussion also covered KAT's inconsistent playoff play and the Mets' 4-3 ten-inning victory over the Dodgers, featuring another Lindor leadoff home run. Other sports news included the Angels' historic three-homer first inning at Fenway, the retirement of the Lions and Patriots centers, and Aaron Judge's inability to leave his hotel due to fan mobs, prompting Boomer to reflect on the impact of phone cameras on athlete privacy.

Hour 2

The conversation began with a nostalgic look at Neptunes, a spot Boomer frequented with his Jets players, and a humorous aside about whether Eddie will cry upon retirement. Larry in Indiana pledged support for Gio in a hypothetical fight with Carl Banks. Jerry's update highlighted the Mets' victory over the Dodgers, with Lindor's leadoff home run and RBI single, though Vientos sustained a hamstring injury. Positive news from Giants camp was tempered by Boomer's reminder that game performance is paramount. Deion Sanders addressed Shedeur's draft rumors, and Bill Simmons expressed frustration with Pablo Torre's coverage of Bill Belichick. The hour concluded with Peter Schwartz discussing his resignation as GM of an arena football team that notably lacked helmets.

Hour 3

The hour began with a discussion of Gio's comments calling Karl-Anthony Towns a "loser," a criticism aimed at his playing style not fitting the Knicks' championship aspirations. Jerry's update covered the Mets' ten-inning victory over the Dodgers, highlighted by Lindor's leadoff home run and RBI single. Charles Barkley's confusing move from TNT to ESPN was also discussed. The segment concluded with Boomer introducing his new twin grandsons and further calls about KAT's inconsistent performance.

Hour 4

Boomer speculated the Knicks would draw high Finals ratings even if people rooted against them, contrasting with smaller markets like Indiana and OKC. We then lamented the decline of memorable sports nicknames. The conversation returned to KAT's playoff performance. Jerry's final update covered the Mets' ten-inning win over the Dodgers, featuring Lindor's leadoff homer, and previewed the Yankees-Guardians series. Other news included Russell Wilson on Malik Nabers joining the Giants, Saquon Barkley addressing the Madden curse, and Mike Francesa's dieting advice. The "Moment of the Day" highlighted David Andrews' rocky retirement speech. The segment concluded with the arrest of an "overseas sports bettor" who threatened Lance McCullers Jr.'s family, sparking a discussion about A-I and "Bad Tiki."