Hour 1

With Boomer, Gio, and Jerry in Pebble Beach, Chris McMonigle and Willie Colon fill in. The Mets were swept and lost their 7th straight, blowing a 5-0 lead, while the Yankees lost 2 of 3 to the Astros, but won on Old Timers’ Day. Both New York teams are struggling and barely clinging to playoff spots. C-Mac believes star players are failing, while Willie emphasizes the need for momentum. C-Lo’s update covers the Mets' woes and the Yankees' loss to Jason Alexander, prompting a Costanza quote. C-Mac finds a Yankees series loss to the Twins unacceptable. A caller expresses pessimism for New York sports, and Willie questions the Yankees' analytical approach.

Hour 2

C-Mac and Willie discuss player perspective on coaching decisions, mispronounced names, and the Mets' losing streak. They debate Brandon Nimmo's comments, Aaron Boone's pitching choice, and the Jets' locker room after losses. They also disagree with a caller about the Mets' trade deadline moves.

Hour 3

The hour begins positively with strong preseason starts for the Giants and Jets. Willie is impressed by the Jets and advises C-Mac on what Aaron Glenn needs for a successful first year, noting that playing starters in preseason can lead to better early-season results. C-Lo returns with an update, starting with the Mets' blown lead and sweep in Milwaukee. The SNY Jets crew had to swim to their hotel after their car flooded, a situation Willie luckily avoided by being in the studio. C-Lo spent the weekend in Nashville, and C-Mac is grateful Willie knows what lederhosen are, unlike Jerry and the rest of the crew. Jaxson Dart had an impressive pro debut, and Tom Brady’s statue was unveiled. The hour concludes with C-Mac telling Willie he'd prefer Dart to sit the entire year but acknowledges it will be difficult if he continues to play well, reminding Willie of the "FIRE IDZIK" signs from 2014.

Hour 4

The hour began with a discussion of Shedeur Sanders' strong preseason debut, noting that Giants and Jets fans would be concerned if he became a good NFL QB, as both teams passed on him. Neither local team's most important player is their QB, and the Giants, though not necessarily good, can't be awful. C-Lo provided an update after C-Mac shared stories about his wife's job, their dating history, and a failed gift. Roger Clemens informed Dave Sims and Suzyn Waldman of Mariano Rivera's Achilles injury at Old Timers’ Day, leading to a segment on the Yankees needing an attitude adjustment. Willie believes Aaron Glenn is gaining his players' trust. The Moment of The Day featured C-Mac's Oktoberfest attire. In the final segment, C-Mac admitted to betting against the Yankees for the past six games due to emotional hedging, which Willie called him a loser for. C-Mac also shared Willie’s fondness for Buc-ee’s.