Hour 1

With Boomer, Gio, and Jerry in Pebble Beach, Chris McMonigle and Willie Colon fill in. The Yankees won, but C-Mac isn't impressed, finding the constant comparison to past teams annoying. Willie agrees, noting the evolution of sports. C-Lo's update highlights the Yankees' relief win and ponders the Mets' Phillies/Reds rooting interest. They expect Pete Alonso to hit his 253rd career HR. Willie dislikes joint practices. The group discusses modern slang and Shedeur Sanders. C-Mac questions how Mets fans would react if Alonso breaks the club HR record in a loss during the team's slump.

Hour 2

C-Mac and Willie discuss the Yankees, Steelers, and Aaron Rodgers. C-Lo provides an update, referencing "The Sandlot" and criticizing modern language. They also touch on Giancarlo Stanton, Aaron Boone, and quarterback criticism, defending Boone while noting areas for improvement.

Hour 3

C-Mac questions if the Mets will finally call up a top pitching prospect to face the Braves, a team they struggle against. C-Mac admires Gerrit Cole's mustache. C-Lo returns with an update, first addressing a previous mistake. John Sterling offered Aaron Boone advice. Willie discovers former WFAN hosts were technologically gullible. The hour ends with the announcement of marquee Knicks game dates and times.

Hour 4

Willie heads to Atlanta, C-Mac to Italy, both embarrassed by their strange algorithms. They debate baseball analytics with an old man and discuss sports entertainment, bathroom reading, and barbershop adult magazines. C-Lo updates on the Yankees' win and Clint Frazier's dislike for the organization. C-Mac discusses the changing role of managers. C-Lo shares more Joe Benigno clips and asks Willie about the 2014 Jets and John Idzik. Willie recounts the team's desire for offseason additions that Idzik refused. The Moment of The Day revisits the McAdoo Disaster. The hour ends with cruise discussions and Giants/Jets practice reports.