Hour 1

Guest hosts Chris McMonigle and Keith McPherson discuss Pete Alonso's new Mets home run record. C-Mac believes Steve Cohen will ensure Alonso remains a Met, while Keith is certain. They also address Clay Holmes' struggles and the Mets' starting pitching concerns. C-Lo's update focuses on Alonso's historic homer and the Mets' six-homer game. C-Mac and Keith debate Gary Cohen's call of the home run and C-Mac highlights Francisco Lindor's key bunt. C-Mac believes Alonso loves being a Met more than any current New York athlete loves being on their team.

Hour 2

The Yankees secured two consecutive wins against the Twins. Carlos Rodon overcame a shaky start to pitch seven strong innings. Anthony Volpe's home run signals a turn in his season. While seeing encouraging signs, the guys still have concerns about the Yankees. A caller comparing the current Yankees to the 90s dynasty irked C-Mac. C-Lo reported on Pete Alonso's record night and Evan Roberts' moon-distracted drive. Giancarlo Stanton had four hits, prompting Syzun and C-Mac to advise caution when running. Jermaine Johnson is back from his achilles injury. The hour ended with a caller praising Brian Cashman, delighting C-Mac and Keith.

Hour 3

The Jets and Giants held their second joint practice. Keith is optimistic about both teams, highlighting Abdul Carter's hype, improved Giants QB play, and Aaron Glenn's impact as Jets HC. C-Mac believes the Giants' pass rush can be dominant and prefers Justin Fields. C-Lo reported on Brandon Nimmo saving the Mets and the Yankees' comeback led by Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. In the final segment, C-Mac recited a monologue, and he and Keith debated the Yankees' playoff chances.

Hour 4

C-Mac worries about Abdul Carter's hype, but Keith assures him the Giants made the right pick. Keith, a free agent fan, explains why he's done with the Cowboys and Jerry Jones, despite C-Mac's loyalty. C-Lo's update includes his favorite song, "Hook" by Blues Traveler, and discussion of the upcoming Taylor Swift "New Heights" podcast. Pete Alonso broke the Mets' all-time home run record, sending a message to Steve Cohen and David Stearns about his future goals, while Keith finds the Mets' scoreboard jokes "little brother energy." Giancarlo Stanton led the Yankees to a win. C-Mac is concerned about Malik Nabers' continued absence from practice, which Keith attributes to avoiding Sauce Gardner. The segment concludes with Keith's bobblehead collecting and C-Mac's lack of interest.