Hour 1

Jerry Recco and Willie Colon fill in for Boomer and Gio. The Yankees salvaged their Red Sox series finale but need more from Aaron Judge and better hitting against good pitchers, unlike the Red Sox who manufacture runs. Anthony Volpe is getting a deserved break. C-Lo discusses his football coaching debut. The Yankees rely on home runs, as seen in their recent win over the Red Sox. The Mets failed to sweep the Braves due to early missed opportunities. Cal Raleigh set a single-season HR record. The Giants are monitoring Tommy DeVito and are unlikely to trade Jameis Winston, who Willie believes would play over Jaxson Dart. Jerry updates Willie on his groundhog and new bat problem.

Hour 2

Jerry and Willie discuss NFL cutdown day, with Willie noting players try to stand out. He believes the Jets still need a better QB despite helping Quinnen Williams, critiquing Fields' NFL struggles compared to his Ohio State days. The Giants must win one of their first two divisional games. C-Lo's update covers Jazz Chisholm Jr.'s two homers helping the Yankees beat the Red Sox, the Mets' loss in Atlanta due to poor hitting with runners in scoring position, Shohei Ohtani's interaction with a heckler, and "The Big Dumper's" record day. Brian Schottenheimer plans to address Micah Parsons' behavior. Tommy Fleetwood won his first PGA Tour Championship, while Daniil Medvedev argued with an umpire after a photographer interrupted play, a reaction Willie understands. The hour concludes with Jerry reflecting on wild live sports moments, including the Malice at the Palace and the World Series earthquake.

Hour 3

The hour began with calls about crazy live sports moments, a topic Jerry couldn't believe we missed. Willie recalled Antonio Brown quitting during a game. A squirrel disrupted the Yankees-Red Sox game, where the Yankees later won 7-2 with homers from Trent Grisham and Jazz Chisholm Jr. The Mets lost to the Braves, and Marlins reliever Tyler Phillips slaps himself before games. The final segment continued with calls about live crazy sports moments.

Hour 4

The final hour includes more calls about crazy sports moments, with Jerry and Willie recalling some and learning others. C-Lo provides his last update after their boss shares a crazy sports moment and Jerry asks Willie about a cruise fight. C-Lo plays audio of a 2002 Royals coach attack, which Willie connects to learning caution. The Yankees won, but the Mets lost. The Moment of the Day: Jerry's bat problem, which Willie couldn't handle. The show ends with another crazy Jets/Shea Stadium moment. Jerry and Eddie both have Shea Stadium grass.