Support Breaking Walls at https://www.patreon.com/thewallbreakers

Bill Spier’s Hollywood Suspense episodes got good reviews. He returned to New York for seven more shows while he got the green light to move Suspense to the West Coast. The first permanent Hollywood show was “Fear Paints a Picture” on April 13th, 1943.

John Dickson Carr continued as writer until June, but Spier began to look for other voices, like Lucille Fletcher, who followed up “The Hitch-hiker” with “The Diary of Sophronia Winters,” starring Agnes Moorehead. The two would reunite a month later, on May 25th, 1943, for the most famous Suspense episode of all-time, “Sorry, Wrong Number.”

Bill Spier did not direct this episode. It was handled by Ted Bliss. Although only thirty-six, Spier had recently suffered a heart attack.

“Sorry, Wrong Number” was so harrowing, and Agnes Moorehead’s tour-de-force performance was so gripping to even the rest of the people in the studio, that a now-famous missed cue happened. I’ll let Ms Moorehead explain.

Although Spier wanted to repeat the broadcast immediately, it was finally redone on August 21st. At that time CBS was in talks with Colgate to sponsor the series. The performance was heavily promoted, along with a time change. Suspense would be moving to Saturdays with this show. The August 21st, 1943 episode was the first time two different productions for each coast were done. CBS was attempting to deliver a large audience to entice Colgate to buy the series. The first broadcast was done at 4:30PM Pacific time for the East, while the second was done at 8PM for local audiences. Here’s the ending to the August 21st, 1943 broadcast of “Sorry, Wrong Number,” coming from the East Coast broadcast, as it was intended to have been performed the first time.

Four days later Variety was enthusiastic in its praise for the broadcast. Hans Conried played the murderer.

Besides the slightly missed cue, why was this story repeated so soon after? CBS was flooded with letters and phone calls. A funny thing happens as you listen to Mrs. Stevenson complain, you begin to like her less and less. This was intentional.

Writer Lucille Fletcher was born in New York City on March 28th, 1912 and patterned the character after snooty women she’d had obnoxious dealings with in New York. At that time, only forty percent of U.S. homes had a phone. The fictional Stevenson home address of North Sutton Place was patterned after Sutton Place in New York City. It was one of the most exclusive areas on Manhattan’s east side.

As researcher Dr. Joseph Webb put it, ​​“regular people” were dealing with the scarcities and uncertainty of the War. Everyone was sacrificing in one way or another or had family members in the service.” Mrs Stevenson’s complaints slowly erode the audience's sympathy for her, but still no one was expecting her to actually be murdered at the end, atypical of climaxes at that time.

Despite the praise, the Saturday experiment ended the following week. Spier recovered from his heart attack and returned on September 23rd, 1943, taking over direction.

Colgate passed on sponsoring the series. Suspense went back to one national broadcast, but by November, Roma Wines would sign on, becoming the sponsor, and increasing Suspense’s budgets exponentially.

#suspense #oldtimeradio #oldtimeradioshows #otr #historypodcast #oldhollywood #mysteryfiction