In this haunting episode of Forgotten Serial Killers, we examine the life of Cary Anthony Stayner—the overlooked older brother of Steven Stayner, whose abduction made national headlines in 1972. While America celebrated Steven’s miraculous return, Cary grew up in the long shadow of that tragedy, eventually becoming the Yosemite serial killer who murdered four women in 1999.

In this haunting episode of Forgotten Serial Killers, we examine the life of Cary Anthony Stayner—the overlooked older brother of Steven Stayner, whose abduction made national headlines in 1972. While America celebrated Steven’s miraculous return, Cary grew up in the long shadow of that tragedy, eventually becoming the Yosemite serial killer who murdered four women in 1999.

Cary Anthony Stayner - The Other Brother

Welcome to Forgotten Serial Killers True Crime — the definitive podcast dedicated to unearthing the most disturbing, overlooked, and deliberately buried stories of serial murderers that mainstream true crime has ignored for decades.While the world obsesses over Ted Bundy, John Wayne Gacy, and Jeffrey Dahmer, hundreds of equally monstrous killers slipped through the cracks of history. Some were too quiet, some too clever, and others simply operated in places or times where the media and police didn’t want to admit the body count. This podcast brings those forgotten monsters back into the spotlight with meticulously researched, deeply unsettling episodes that go far beyond surface-level recaps.Each week, we deliver a full-length deep dive (45–70 minutes) into one forgotten serial killer or a cluster of connected cases. You’ll hear chilling timelines of their crimes, detailed victim profiles that honor the lives stolen, exhaustive analysis of how investigators missed (or covered up) the patterns, psychological breakdowns backed by expert insights, and the cultural or systemic reasons these cases were pushed into obscurity.From the quiet suburban nurse who killed dozens of patients over twenty years without raising alarms, to the traveling salesman who left a trail of bodies across multiple states in the 1960s, to international predators whose crimes were lost in political chaos or poor record-keeping — we chase down every lead, no matter how cold.What makes Forgotten Serial Killers True Crime different:<ul><li>No sensationalism, just facts — We use court documents, police reports, archived newspapers, and interviews with investigators or surviving family members whenever possible.</li><li>Victim-focused storytelling — Every killer’s story is told through the lives they destroyed, not glorified.</li><li>Psychology &amp; forensics — We explore signature behaviors, missed red flags, evolving MO, and what modern criminology reveals about these overlooked cases.</li><li>The “why forgotten” angle — Why did the media ignore this killer? Was it racism, classism, jurisdictional failures, or something more sinister?</li><li>Listener community — Submit your own forgotten cases or tips via our website. Many episodes are now driven by listener discoveries.</li></ul>Whether you’re a longtime true crime addict tired of hearing the same ten stories repeated, or someone new looking for fresh, horrifying content, this podcast delivers. Expect episodes on:<ul><li>The “Gentleman Killer” of 1940s New England</li><li>Female serial killers history erased from textbooks</li><li>Cross-country transients who murdered for decades undetected</li><li>Small-town monsters protected by local corruption</li><li>International cases almost no American has ever heard</li></ul>Hosted with a calm, respectful, yet gripping narrative style that lets the horror speak for itself. No theatrical screaming, no cheap sound effects — just powerful storytelling, haunting music beds, and the occasional expert guest from criminology and forensic psychology.New episodes drop every Tuesday. Perfect for late-night drives, workouts, or when you can’t sleep because the details won’t leave your mind.If you love deep, dark, well-researched true crime that actually teaches you something new about human evil, subscribe now and never miss an episode of Forgotten Serial Killers True Crime.Join thousands of listeners who are finally learning the names they should have known all along.Available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, and everywhere else.Forgotten Serial Killers True Crime — Because some monsters don’t deserve to stay buried.

True Crime

Welcome to Forgotten Serial Killers True Crime — the definitive podcast dedicated to unearthing the most disturbing, overlooked, and deliberately buried stories of serial murderers that mainstream true crime has ignored for decades. While the world obsesses over Ted Bundy, John Wayne Gacy, and Jeffrey Dahmer, hundreds of equally monstrous killers slipped through the cracks of history. Some were too quiet, some too clever, and others simply operated in places or times where the media and police didn’t want to admit the body count. This podcast brings those forgotten monsters back into the spotlight with meticulously researched, deeply unsettling episodes that go far beyond surface-level recaps. Each week, we deliver a full-length deep dive (45–70 minutes) into one forgotten serial killer or a cluster of connected cases. You’ll hear chilling timelines of their crimes, detailed victim profiles that honor the lives stolen, exhaustive analysis of how investigators missed (or covered up) the patterns, psychological breakdowns backed by expert insights, and the cultural or systemic reasons these cases were pushed into obscurity. From the quiet suburban nurse who killed dozens of patients over twenty years without raising alarms, to the traveling salesman who left a trail of bodies across multiple states in the 1960s, to international predators whose crimes were lost in political chaos or poor record-keeping — we chase down every lead, no matter how cold. What makes Forgotten Serial Killers True Crime different:No sensationalism, just facts — We use court documents, police reports, archived newspapers, and interviews with investigators or surviving family members whenever possible.Victim-focused storytelling — Every killer’s story is told through the lives they destroyed, not glorified.Psychology & forensics — We explore signature behaviors, missed red flags, evolving MO, and what modern criminology reveals about these overlooked cases.The “why forgotten” angle — Why did the media ignore this killer? Was it racism, classism, jurisdictional failures, or something more sinister?Listener community — Submit your own forgotten cases or tips via our website. Many episodes are now driven by listener discoveries.Whether you’re a longtime true crime addict tired of hearing the same ten stories repeated, or someone new looking for fresh, horrifying content, this podcast delivers. Expect episodes on:The “Gentleman Killer” of 1940s New EnglandFemale serial killers history erased from textbooksCross-country transients who murdered for decades undetectedSmall-town monsters protected by local corruptionInternational cases almost no American has ever heardHosted with a calm, respectful, yet gripping narrative style that lets the horror speak for itself. No theatrical screaming, no cheap sound effects — just powerful storytelling, haunting music beds, and the occasional expert guest from criminology and forensic psychology. New episodes drop every Tuesday. Perfect for late-night drives, workouts, or when you can’t sleep because the details won’t leave your mind. If you love deep, dark, well-researched true crime that actually teaches you something new about human evil, subscribe now and never miss an episode of Forgotten Serial Killers True Crime. Join thousands of listeners who are finally learning the names they should have known all along. Available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, and everywhere else. Forgotten Serial Killers True Crime — Because some monsters don’t deserve to stay buried.

Share Cary Anthony Stayner - The Other Brother

Sign up to save your podcasts

Cary Anthony Stayner - The Other Brother

Cary Anthony Stayner - The Other Brother