In this chilling episode, we take you back to the cold December day in 2010, when a routine search for a missing woman on Long Island’s South Shore led to a terrifying discovery. What started as a hunt for one victim quickly escalated into the unearthing of multiple bodies. Join us as we dive into the initial police investigation, the uncovering of the remains along Ocean Parkway, and the questions that continue to haunt investigators and families alike. Who were these women, and how did their bodies come to rest on the lonely stretch of Gilgo Beach? Through expert analysis and a detailed timeline, we explore the dark reality that exposed one of New York’s most notorious serial killers.

This episode offers a gripping look into the earliest phase of the Long Island Serial Killer case, unraveling the discoveries that shocked a community and launched a years-long investigation.