When the DA’s office hauls Jared and Jonathan into the hot seat for "misconduct involving poor taste and highly questionable movie selections," the Gumshoes are given one last shot to redeem themselves. Their assignment? Investigate the bizarre 2019 thriller-comedy Butt Boy a film where a mild-mannered IT man develops a highly unusual addiction: making objects (and eventually people) disappear… where the sun don’t shine.

As the Gumshoes sift through this absurdly deadpan noir, they’ll follow the trail of missing persons, shrinking objects, and increasingly uncomfortable metaphors. Is Butt Boy an oddly brilliant satire on addiction and compulsion, or just a film that shouldn’t exist? With their careers on the line and the DA breathing down their necks, Jared and Jonathan dive into the abyss (so to speak), determined to crack the case… and maybe their own dignity.