While the Movie Gumshoes were hard at work launching their totally legitimate, not-at-all-illegal side hustle—BoxOfficeBetsDotCom—they stumbled onto a psychological thriller that had “bad vibes” written all over it. In Scott Beck and Bryan Woods’ latest flick, two young missionaries knock on the wrong door and wind up in a theological cage match with the sinister Mr. Reed—played by none other than Hugh Grant, apparently auditioning for the role of “British Devil.”

Trapped in his home, with nowhere to run and no prayers left unanswered, they’ll need more than scripture to survive. Also starring Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East, this one’s a holy house of horrors—and the odds are not in their favor.