Imagine if you brought your new boyfriend over to meet your parents and he ends up murdering your entire family. Meet Charles Starkweather, a nineteen year old who went on a murder spree killing 11 people from December of 1957 to January 1958 with his 13-year old accomplice/girlfriend Caril Ann Fugate. Caril has since maintained her innocence claiming she was never a willing accomplice but a hostage instead, yet evidence suggests otherwise. Do you think she was innocent or a willing accomplice all along?