Originally Aired: January 31, 1960

Gunsmoke #408, "Chester's Dilemma,"

Chester finds himself the object of affection from Edna, a young store clerk working for Mr. Jonas who transforms from a wilted shopgirl into a radiant companion each afternoon at closing time. The pretty but mysterious woman, who Jonas suspects is hiding something about her farm upbringing in Ohio, begins accompanying Chester on his daily mail runs from the depot. She clings to his arm, flatters his bravery, and shows unusual interest in the marshal's correspondence, particularly the wanted circulars and official letters.

Meanwhile, Doc McGee diagnoses Chester with a different ailment: he's become listless and distracted, neglecting his duties at the marshal's office. Doc suggests to Matt Dillon that Chester feels unappreciated, but the real cause of Chester's preoccupation becomes clear when Edna kisses him on Front Street and takes a particular interest in a letter from Ohio. As Chester struggles between his duties and this new romance, Edna's secretive behavior and her focus on the marshal's mail hint at complications ahead for Dodge City's lovesick deputy.