On July 16, 1979, at approximately 5:30 a.m., an earthen dam at the United Nuclear Corporation uranium mill in Church Rock, New Mexico, breached.

The tailings pond behind it held acidic liquid waste and radioactive solids from uranium processing. When the dam gave way, an estimated 94 million gallons of contaminated liquid and roughly 1,100 tons of radioactive mill waste surged into Pipeline Arroyo and into the Rio Puerco.

It remains the largest accidental release of radioactive material in United States history.

It happened just four months after Three Mile Island.

One event dominated national headlines and congressional hearings.

The other mostly didn’t.

Where It Happened

Church Rock sits just east of Gallup, New Mexico, along Interstate 40, on the western edge of the Navajo Nation.

The Rio Puerco is typically a dry wash, running seasonally after storms. When it runs, it carries whatever sits upstream.

That July morning, it carried uranium mill waste.

Why It Failed

The tailings dam was constructed of compacted earth, raised incrementally as the pond filled. Cracks and seepage had been documented prior to the breach. Later reviews pointed to foundation instability and uneven settlement beneath portions of the dam.

There was no explosion.No dramatic plume.Just structural failure under sustained load.

The system functioned the way it had been allowed to.

Immediate Impact

Radioactive water traveled downstream across Navajo land.

Sheep drank from it.

Livestock deaths were reported in the days that followed. Families who relied on those animals for food and income absorbed the losses first.

No immediate human fatalities were recorded.

That absence shaped how the story was treated nationally.

Legal Fallout

The Navajo Nation filed suit against United Nuclear Corporation. In 1983, a $10 million settlement was reached.

It was compensation for livestock loss and land damage.

It was not restoration.

In 1990, Congress passed the Radiation Exposure Compensation Act, acknowledging harm to uranium workers and certain affected populations during the Cold War era. It took more than a decade after the spill for that recognition to exist in law.

Even then, not all impacted residents qualified.

The Long Tail

Hundreds of abandoned uranium mines remain across the Navajo Nation today.

Contamination in sediment and soil from the Rio Puerco area has been documented for decades. The Church Rock site later became part of long-term federal cleanup efforts.

The spill did not disappear.

It simply stopped being discussed.

Why This Matters

In 1979, America was already focused on nuclear safety.

Three Mile Island triggered national panic, televised coverage, and sweeping debate.

Church Rock released more radioactive material into the environment.

It did not become shorthand.

There were no anniversary specials.

No ritualized remembrance.

Just paperwork.

If you listened to the episode, you already know this isn’t about spectacle.

It’s about scale.

It’s about risk that doesn’t announce itself loudly enough.

It’s about the difference between an event that becomes cultural memory and one that becomes a footnote.

And if you’ve read this far, you are now among the minority who know the name Church Rock.

If you want to support independent storytelling that goes digging through inspection reports and forgotten enforcement actions instead of doom scrolling, paulgnewton.com has the usual suspects.

History does not always roar.

Sometimes it leaks.

Get full access to Paul G's Corner at paulgnewton.substack.com/subscribe