The central theme of our discourse revolves around the characterization of churches based on their congregational demographics and the implications of such labels, particularly the term "gay church." We contend that the designation of a church as a "gay church" is not merely contingent upon the sexual orientation of its attendees, but rather it is fundamentally rooted in the doctrinal teachings and cultural ethos espoused by that congregation. We explore the assertion that if attendance was the sole criterion for classification, then all churches in Atlanta could be deemed "gay churches," a conclusion that merits rigorous examination. Furthermore, we critically analyze the ramifications of theological positions that endorse or condone homosexual behavior, positing that such teachings fundamentally undermine the essence of what constitutes a true church in accordance with biblical standards. Ultimately, our discussion seeks to illuminate the distinction between the presence of individuals with same-sex attractions within a church and the church's overarching theological stance regarding such lifestyles, advocating for a return to scriptural fidelity in defining the church's identity.