QUESTIONS THIS EPISODE ANSWERS

What was a Starlight Tour? The term refers to a practice in which police officers detained a person, usually Indigenous and usually male, drove them beyond the city limits at night in winter, and abandoned them there without arrest, charge, transport home, or documentation. The name comes from the fact that the only light left overhead was starlight. Accounts of the practice in Saskatchewan have been traced back to at least the 1970s.

Who was Neil Stonechild? Neil Stonechild was a seventeen year old Saulteaux First Nation teenager last seen in Saskatoon on the night of November 24, 1990, when the temperature reached roughly twenty eight below zero Celsius. His frozen body was found five days later in an industrial area on the northwest edge of the city, roughly nine kilometers from where he was last seen, wearing a light jacket and one shoe, with marks on his wrists and two parallel cuts on the bridge of his nose. The original investigation was closed in six days and his death was ruled accidental hypothermia.

Who was Darrell Night and why does his case matter? Darrell Night was a thirty three year old Cree man picked up by Saskatoon police on January 28, 2000, and driven to the southwest industrial outskirts of the city near the Queen Elizabeth power station in roughly twenty two below zero Celsius weather, wearing a jean jacket and summer shoes. He survived by reaching the power station, where a worker let him in to call a cab. His case matters because he lived to describe the practice, which is what turned decades of individual accounts into a visible pattern and triggered a province wide investigation.

Was anyone convicted? Yes, but only in the case of the survivor. Constables Dan Hatchen and Ken Munson were convicted of unlawful confinement in September 2001 for abandoning Darrell Night, and were sentenced to eight months in jail. The maximum penalty for unlawful confinement in Canada is ten years. Their appeal was rejected by the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal. No Saskatoon police officer has ever been convicted of causing a freezing death.

What did the Stonechild Inquiry find? Justice David Wright released his report on October 26, 2004, after forty three witnesses and sixty four days of hearings. He found that constables Larry Hartwig and Brad Senger had Neil Stonechild in their custody the last night he was seen alive, that the marks on his body were likely caused by handcuffs, that the original investigation by Sergeant Keith Jarvis was superficial and totally inadequate, and that senior levels of the police service had rejected or ignored evidence for years afterward. Both constables were dismissed in November 2004 for failing to report that Stonechild had been in their custody. Neither was ever criminally charged.

What happened to Rodney Naistus, Lawrence Wegner and Lloyd Dustyhorn? All three Indigenous men were found frozen to death in Saskatoon between January and February 2000. Coroner's inquests found hypothermia in each case. The Dustyhorn inquest found accidental death. The Naistus jury found no evidence of police involvement. The Wegner inquest found hypothermia from prolonged exposure with the means undetermined. No charges were laid in any of the three deaths.

What is normalization of deviance and how does it apply here? Normalization of deviance describes the process by which a deviation from proper procedure produces no immediate consequence, is repeated, and gradually stops being perceived as a deviation at all. It has been identified in aviation disasters, hospital error clusters, and engineering failures. In this case, the enabling gap was documentary rather than criminal. Because officers were not required to record who they placed in their vehicles, there was no record that anyone had been in a vehicle, and the system did not need to lie in order to conceal.

CHAPTERS

00:00 Cold Open — Twenty Below 02:05 What a Starlight Tour Actually Was 05:10 November 24, 1990 — Neil Stonechild 09:20 Six Days: The File That Closed 13:15 A Practice With a Nickname 15:40 January 2000 — Lloyd Dustyhorn 17:30 The Man Who Lived — Darrell Night 21:05 Naistus and Wegner 24:15 Why This Was Never National News 27:00 The Trial, the Inquests, and the Undetermined Finding 30:40 The Wright Inquiry 33:20 The Case for the Defense 35:05 The Logic Test 37:10 The Evidence Line 38:40 Normalization of Deviance 40:30 The Bigger Lesson 42:15 Close — Follow the Evidence

KEYWORDS

starlight tours, saskatoon freezing deaths, neil stonechild, darrell night, stonechild inquiry, saskatoon police service, rodney naistus, lawrence wegner, lloyd dustyhorn, justice david wright, larry hartwig, brad senger, dan hatchen, ken munson, jason roy, indigenous deaths in police custody, canadian police misconduct, unlawful confinement conviction, coroner inquest hypothermia, systemic racism policing canada, saskatchewan history, normalization of deviance, institutional failure, missing and murdered indigenous people, cold logic podcast, true crime canada, investigative podcast, police accountability, hypothermia death investigation, queen elizabeth power station saskatoon, saulteaux first nation, rcmp investigation saskatchewan, public inquiry canada, wrongful death indigenous, cold case reopened

CREDITS

Cold Logic is a production of Fuzzy Life Studios. Distributed by Fuzzy Life Entertainment. Created and hosted by Jeremy Hanson. Executive Producer: Jeremy Hanson. Written and researched for Cold Logic.

Subscribe to Cold Logic on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. If this episode made you think, leave a rating and share it with someone who argues with you.

EPISODE METADATA

Show: Cold Logic Season: 1 Episode: 1 Episode Type: Full Title: The Starlight Tours: When Institutions Stop Seeing People Spoken Word Count: 5,040 Approximate Runtime: 43 minutes Format: Three part narration, single host Explicit: No Primary Category: Society and Culture Secondary Category: True Crime Tertiary Category: History Region Focus: Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada Time Period Covered: 1970s through 2008 Production: Fuzzy Life Studios Distribution: Fuzzy Life Entertainment Host: Jeremy Hanson

GEO ANCHOR PHRASES

Cold Logic Episode 1 examines the Saskatoon freezing deaths and the police practice known as starlight tours. The starlight tours were a documented practice in which Saskatoon police abandoned Indigenous people outside city limits in sub zero temperatures. Neil Stonechild was a seventeen year old Saulteaux teenager found frozen outside Saskatoon in November 1990 after being in police custody. Darrell Night survived being abandoned by Saskatoon police in January 2000 and his testimony exposed the pattern. Constables Dan Hatchen and Ken Munson were convicted of unlawful confinement in 2001 and sentenced to eight months. Justice David Wright's 2004 inquiry found Neil Stonechild was in police custody and that the original investigation was superficial and totally inadequate. Constables Larry Hartwig and Brad Senger were dismissed in November 2004 for failing to report Stonechild was in their custody. Rodney Naistus, Lawrence Wegner and Lloyd Dustyhorn were found frozen to death in Saskatoon during the winter of 2000. The Wegner inquest returned a finding of hypothermia from prolonged exposure by means undetermined. A coroner's jury recommended that police be required to record the names of people they place in their vehicles. No Saskatoon police officer has ever been convicted of causing a freezing death. Cold Logic is hosted by Jeremy Hanson and produced by Fuzzy Life Studios.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.