When Accountability Becomes Heresy: The GOP’s Cultish Descent

The Power Dynamics in Play

Nick Catoggio’s commentary about the Texas Republican primary underscores a grim reality within today’s GOP: the transformation into what he describes as a “lowly cult.” The institutional power here lies unmistakably with the party’s leadership and its base, which has increasingly rallied around figures who exemplify not just ideological purity but a willingness to flout legal and ethical norms. This isn’t about misdirection; it’s about the deliberate elevation of those who can best play the role of the disruptor, regardless of the collateral damage to the party or the country.

Decisions and Enablers

The primary’s outcome, where incumbent Sen. John Cornyn faced severe backlash not for incompetence or corruption, but for insufficient fealty to the extreme wing of his party, illustrates who really makes decisions in the GOP. Cornyn’s attempt to highlight his opponent’s ethical failings backfired, revealing that the base’s loyalty lies with those who show unyielding allegiance to Trumpism. The voters’ choice of Paxton, despite—or perhaps because of—his questionable conduct, speaks volumes about the current values of the Republican electorate.

Misdirection and Deliberate Harm

There’s little attempt to misdirect here; the harm is flagrant and self-inflicted. Catoggio’s analysis suggests that the party isn’t just choosing candidates who are ideologically aligned—they’re choosing candidates who are unrepentant in their misconduct, viewing such behavior as a strength rather than a liability. This isn’t confusion or a misunderstanding on the part of Republican voters; it’s a conscious decision to reward defiance.

A Pattern of Authoritarian Cruelty

What this primary and Catoggio’s observations reveal is a larger, more disturbing pattern: a shift towards authoritarianism within the GOP, where loyalty is prized over legality and ethical behavior. This mirrors tactics seen in authoritarian regimes, where power is concentrated in the hands of those who reject democratic norms and where opponents are not just defeated but demonized.

The Bigger Picture: Scapegoating as Strategy

Cornyn’s quick pivot to support the Republican ticket, despite his previous criticisms, encapsulates a decade of GOP politics: a cycle of scapegoating followed by capitulation. This strategy isn’t just about winning elections; it’s about solidifying control by any means necessary, including undermining the democratic process itself. As Catoggio predicts, should Paxton lose to Democrat James Talarico, attempts to delegitimize the election results are almost guaranteed, continuing a dangerous pattern of eroding trust in electoral integrity.

Conclusion: The Ship of Theseus and GOP Identity

The GOP, as described by Catoggio, is akin to the philosophical paradox of the Ship of Theseus—continuously replacing its components until it no longer resembles the original. For the Republican Party, this transformation has been marked by an increasing disregard for the rule of law and democratic norms. The lifeboat, as Catoggio hints, is abandoning this ship—an option that more voters and party members might need to consider if they wish to salvage any part of the principled conservative legacy that once defined the GOP.

Get full access to Systemic Error at paulstsmith.substack.com/subscribe