The Creep From A Few Years Ago by JJ_p79

Lonely Lucy by CanadianGal3

"Jack" Gave Me My Peace of Mind Back by Alex

Housesitting by Lanky_Pack_881

Model by Reddit user Walkingonmarstonight
Acting Naive by Reddit user Unprettyhabits
Paranormal Corrections by Reddit user Parzyfail
The Mimic by Katie

I May Need To Find a New Gym by Reddit user Pipercross23
What Was She Planning To Do To Me? by Reddit user kennyc5576
Hero or Reaper by blosomes
Demogorgon Screams by MsRevz

Be Careful Who You Match With by Reddit user Ms-Kyyyaaa
Mr. G by Sierra
Come Out, Come Out Wherever You Are by Jason
And The Skies Are Gray by Reddit user vo1ces

New Years Creeper by Reddit user Due-Entertainer2639
Gut Instincts by Lacie
Extraordinary Visitations by Reddit user drowsy_dreamer
Mistaken Identity, Prank Call, Something Else? by Reddit user dastardlydaggerz

Peeping Tom Creep by Reddit user Jade-E-Green
Lady at The Back Door by Sierra
Bobita by Mimi
Elevator Horror by Author Unknown

Psycho Chase by FM
I Survived My Country by Star
Oregon Duplex by Morrison
The Whispers by Reddit user Excellent_Reach6641

Stacy by I'd Rather Not Say

Nightmare Date With My Ex by Throwaway
The Prints by POTO
Strange Encounter by Reddit user thatgal7777
Forest Cryptid by Joanna H. from Liveabout.com

Bad Policeman by Angel
Cul-de-sac Guy by Reddit user xXxuhbatzxXx
The Button Man by Reddit user suziedrafton
The Pulau Langkawi Girls' Hostel by Reddit user Excellent_Reach6641