🎲 Crits&Chaos – Episode 7: Managing Metagaming: Keeping the Game in the Game

We’ve all seen it happen — the dice are rolling, the party’s deep in character, and then someone blurts out: “Wait, I know this monster’s weakness!” That’s metagaming, and it can shatter immersion faster than a crit fail on a stealth check.

In this episode of Crits&Chaos, I break down what metagaming actually is and share 10 Crit Tips for handling it at the table. From turning slips into story hooks, to mixing up monster lore, to rewarding players who stay in character — this one’s all about keeping the game in the game.

Metagaming isn’t the end of the world — it’s a sign your players are engaged. The trick is learning how to guide it back into the story so it feels natural and fun for everyone.