Trigger Warning: This episode contains discussion of child endangerment, abduction, and sexual abuse. Listener discretion is advised.

In Staten Island, New York, children whispered warnings about an escaped mental patient known as Cropsey. Once dismissed as an urban legend, the story took a darker turn when kids began disappearing under mysterious circumstances.

Join us as we explore the eerie legend of Cropsey, examining the blurred lines between myth and reality and the possibility that this terrifying figure may have been more than just a story. Stick around for our Crime On Tap discussion, where we unpack the case (and our choice of brews) in our signature style.

Grab a brew and follow the clues.