Today on Dave Does History on Bill Mick Live, we’re diving into the life, legacy, and legend of one of America’s most peculiar presidents—Grover Cleveland.

You might not think much about the man who was both the 22nd and 24th president of the United States, but Cleveland was one of the most unique and controversial figures to ever occupy the White House.

Born on this day in 1837, he was the first president to serve two nonconsecutive terms—booted out of office in 1888, only to claw his way back four years later. But his presidency was more than just an interesting footnote in history books.