On July 4th, 1988, high school sweethearts Shane Stewart and Sally McNelly vanished after watching fireworks in San Angelo, Texas. Months later, their remains were discovered near O.C. Fisher Lake — and the mystery surrounding their deaths has haunted the community for over three decades.

Whispers of cult involvement, stolen weapons, and the shadow of the Satanic Panic era only deepened the case’s chilling reputation. Despite suspects, rumors, and even national attention, their murders remain unsolved.

What We Cover:

⚠️ Content Warning:

This episode includes discussion of teen victims, cult activity, and murder. Listener discretion is advised.

Join the Conversation:

What do you think really happened to Shane and Sally? Share your thoughts with us:

Instagram: @DeadEndsPod