Frank Spring from Altum Insight joins Molly to dissect the controversial “Deciding to Win” report from Welcome PAC and what it reveals about the Democratic Party’s identity crisis. With deep expertise in narrative research and voter behavior, Frank challenges the report’s centrist conclusions and explores whether the party has gone “too far left” or if the real problem lies elsewhere. This conversation digs into material politics, the wealthy elite as villains, populist candidates, and what Americans actually want from their political leaders.

KEY TOPICS:

* The “Deciding to Win” Report - Analysis of Welcome PAC’s diagnosis that Democrats need to become more moderate and abandon “unpopular” positions.

* The Vending Machine Theory of Voters - Why the consultant class fundamentally misunderstands how people form political identities and make voting decisions.

* Material Politics vs. Identity Politics - The Democratic Party’s struggle to define its relationship with big money, capital, and corporate power.

* The Wealthy Elite as Villains - How Americans are organically creating a new archetype of the “wealthy elite” as a problem, from Epstein to billionaires.

* Eric Platner and Populism - The promise and problems of populist candidates, including the recent controversy.

* What Comes Next - Practical steps including mutual aid, the No Kings protests, and the possibility of a general strike.

TIMESTAMPED CHAPTERS:

* 00:00:00 - Introduction - Molly introduces Frank Spring and the “Deciding to Win” report that opens with a Nancy Pelosi quote.

* 00:02:15 - What is Welcome PAC? - Frank explains the organization behind the report and their centrist thesis.

* 00:05:30 - The Strawman Problem - How the report misrepresents Democratic positions like “abolishing the police” that aren’t actual party platforms.

* 00:12:45 - What Altum Does - Frank describes their narrative-focused research methodology and qualitative approach.

* 00:15:20 - The Diversity Problem That Isn’t - Research findings show people don’t know what Democrats stand for beyond diversity and inclusivity.

* 00:22:10 - The Trans Agenda Myth - Why even Republicans found the anti-trans campaign “weird” and mean-spirited.

* 00:28:40 - Big Money and Capital - The Democratic Party’s unresolved relationship with big tech, big pharma, and corporate power.

* 00:35:15 - The Vending Machine Theory - Frank’s critique of how consultants think voters work versus how they actually make decisions.

* 00:42:30 - Crime Politics and Reality - Why Americans don’t want “hang ‘em and flog ‘em” politics despite concerns about crime.

* 00:51:20 - Eric Platner Discussion - The promise of naming billionaires as villains and the Nazi tattoo controversy.

* 01:05:45 - Racism and American Politics - How Americans overestimate racism in others and the complexity of voter behavior.

* 01:15:30 - Prison Labor and the Carceral State - Why criminal justice reform referendums succeed even in conservative states.

* 01:22:10 - What Do We Do Next? - Frank’s call to action: give to food banks, show up to protests, take care of each other.

* 01:28:40 - The General Strike Question - Discussion of labor organizing, collective action, and rebuilding atrophied muscles.

* 01:35:15 - Closing Thoughts - The power of the American people and the direction of travel.

GUEST INFORMATION:

* Frank Spring - Altum Insight - Narrative Strategist and Political Analyst. Brief bio highlighting their expertise and connection to the topic: Specializes in behavioral science and cognitive neuroscience of storytelling. Conducts deep qualitative research on political identity formation.

* LinkedIn Profile Link

* X (Twitter) Profile Link

* Altum Insight Website

EPISODE SIGNIFICANCE:

This episode matters because it cuts through the noise of conventional political wisdom to examine how voters actually think and what the Democratic Party’s real problems are. At a moment when:

“We are still not going to be saved by someone else. The most powerful thing we can do is go to the next No Kings protest, take care of each other, and turn up in numbers they can’t ignore.”

— Frank Spring

* The Democratic Party is having its perennial “too far left vs. too centrist” debate. Explanation of why this reason is significant.

* Americans are facing unprecedented attacks on social programs and democratic norms. Explanation of why this reason is significant.

* Grassroots movements like No Kings are showing the power of collective action. Explanation of why this reason is significant.

* The relationship between citizens and the wealthy elite is fundamentally shifting. Explanation of why this reason is significant.

Frank’s research-backed insights reveal that the problem isn’t that Democrats have gone too far left on policy—it’s that the party hasn’t figured out its relationship to capital and power. The “vending machine theory” he describes explains why so much political consulting fails: it assumes people make rational policy-based decisions when they actually form complex identities based on stories, trust, and whether they believe a candidate understands their lives.

CALL TO ACTION:

* Give to Your Local Food Bank - Give so much it hurts. Postpone something you were looking forward to and donate that money instead.

* Show Up to No Kings Protests - The next wave of protests is coming. Your presence matters and sends a message to leadership.

* Take Care of Each Other - Build mutual aid networks in your community. We have to demonstrate we can support each other.

* Prepare for Collective Action - Start thinking about what a general strike would mean and how you could participate.

* Stop Waiting for a Savior - No single candidate will fix this. The power lies in collective action and sustained pressure.

* Challenge the Vending Machine Theory - When you hear political consultants talk about “the issues voters care about,” remember that’s not how people actually make decisions.

RESOURCES & LINKS:

Official Organizations/Websites

* Altum Insight

* Welcome PAC

* No Kings Movement

* Local Food Banks

Follow on Social Media

* Frank Spring (LinkedIn)

* Frank Spring (X/Twitter)

* Molly (Substack)

* #NoKings

* #GeneralStrike

* #MutualAid

Topics to Research

* The “Deciding to Win” report from Welcome PAC

* Vending machine theory of voters

* Eric Platner Maine Senate campaign

* No Kings protest movement

* General strike organizing

* Prison labor abolition referendums

* Crime statistics vs. perception in American cities

* Democratic Party platform history

CLOSING MESSAGE:

The Power Is With the People

This conversation reveals a fundamental truth: Americans are not waiting for permission to build the country they want to live in. From the unprecedented No Kings protests to the organic emergence of the “wealthy elite” as villains in the American story, people are writing a new narrative about power, democracy, and who this country serves.

The Democratic Party’s identity crisis isn’t about being too far left or too centrist on policy—it’s about having the courage to clearly state whose side they’re on. Are they with big money and corporate power, or are they with the people struggling under the weight of precarity, rising costs, and a system rigged against them?

We don’t need another savior. We need each other.

Share this episode with someone who’s trying to make sense of where we go from here. Subscribe to support independent political analysis that challenges conventional wisdom. And most importantly: give to your food bank, show up when it matters, and take care of each other.

Thank you for listening. The work continues. The power is ours if we choose to use it together.

Get full access to What do we do next? at whatdowedonext.substack.com/subscribe