For a generation, anybody with even a little familiarity with baseball knew of Derek Jeter. As the captain of a Yankees dynasty, the author of memorable postseason moments, and the inspiration for so many kids playing shortstop, Derek Jeter was baseball's icon. Was Derek Jeter overrated as a player though? Some people will point to his suspect defense or his lack of MVPs and batting titles to contend that he shouldn't be a first ballot Hall of Famer. But don't forget that Jeter has a top-20 offensive WAR and was an incredibly consistent hitter. All this (and more) on today's episode.