Aaron Judge’s playful bullpen gesture after Drew Rasmussen was removed leads Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber into a debate over whether the moment was harmless fun or strangely out of character. They examine why the reaction might feel different depending on which player made the gesture and whether Judge was simply trying to loosen up a tense Yankees dugout.

The conversation also turns to leadership, personality, and the pressure surrounding a struggling team. Plus, a caller offers Evan a mysterious Jets collectible, prompting a passionate defense of Mo Lewis and a discussion about how one famous play unfairly overshadowed the rest of his career.