
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Send us a text
The magic is real, but so is the tension: we love Disney with our whole hearts, and we’re wrestling with the wave of live action remakes redefining the studio’s legacy. From the early triumph of Snow White to recent revivals of Belle, Lilo & Stitch, and rumors around Tangled, we unpack what’s gained, what’s lost, and why animation still carries a kind of wonder that realism can’t easily duplicate.
We start by laying out where this short series is headed and why we’re passionate about the topic. There’s no Disney slander here—just a candid fan perspective. Animation isn’t a stepping stone to a “real” version; it’s a distinct language with its own rules for movement, expression, and emotion. When stories born in that language migrate to live action, the charm can shift. Sometimes it deepens with fresh context or more grounded characters. Other times it trades lyricism for literalism and leaves viewers nostalgic for the shape, rhythm, and timing that once made every frame sing.
Together we consider what a better path forward could look like: honoring the classics as finished compositions while commissioning new tales that push the medium’s strengths. We talk first principles—clear artistic intent, bold visual choices, music that carries narrative weight—and we make the case for returning to the tiny-room creativity that birthed Mickey and set the standard for the industry. Loving Disney means calling for work that feels inevitable in the medium it inhabits, not just inevitable at the box office.
If you care about the craft behind the magic, you’ll feel right at home with this conversation. Listen, weigh in, and help us map the future we want to see from the studio that taught us how to dream. If this resonates, subscribe, share with a friend, and tell us: which remake worked for you—and which classic should stay animated forever?
By Drew and Peg ShustekSend us a text
The magic is real, but so is the tension: we love Disney with our whole hearts, and we’re wrestling with the wave of live action remakes redefining the studio’s legacy. From the early triumph of Snow White to recent revivals of Belle, Lilo & Stitch, and rumors around Tangled, we unpack what’s gained, what’s lost, and why animation still carries a kind of wonder that realism can’t easily duplicate.
We start by laying out where this short series is headed and why we’re passionate about the topic. There’s no Disney slander here—just a candid fan perspective. Animation isn’t a stepping stone to a “real” version; it’s a distinct language with its own rules for movement, expression, and emotion. When stories born in that language migrate to live action, the charm can shift. Sometimes it deepens with fresh context or more grounded characters. Other times it trades lyricism for literalism and leaves viewers nostalgic for the shape, rhythm, and timing that once made every frame sing.
Together we consider what a better path forward could look like: honoring the classics as finished compositions while commissioning new tales that push the medium’s strengths. We talk first principles—clear artistic intent, bold visual choices, music that carries narrative weight—and we make the case for returning to the tiny-room creativity that birthed Mickey and set the standard for the industry. Loving Disney means calling for work that feels inevitable in the medium it inhabits, not just inevitable at the box office.
If you care about the craft behind the magic, you’ll feel right at home with this conversation. Listen, weigh in, and help us map the future we want to see from the studio that taught us how to dream. If this resonates, subscribe, share with a friend, and tell us: which remake worked for you—and which classic should stay animated forever?