This case brings us to the mystery of the murder of Donna Dima Chao, a 19-year-old girl who disappeared in 1984 and was found dead 11 years later in the woods of Cranberry Farm, New Jersey. Nearly four decades without answers, the case was finally solved thanks to modern DNA technology that linked bodily fluids in Donna's bedroom to Nathaniel Harvey—a repeat offender also involved in the axe murder of Irene Schnapps and brutal attacks on other victims. Harvey's initial confession was overturned due to a Miranda rights violation, and physical evidence such as size 6 shoe prints matching the blood at the crime scene was also overlooked, showing how procedural errors can allow killers to remain free.
In this episode, you will learn how forensic technology can uncover old crimes, how lost evidence can finally reveal the truth, and the dangers of repeat offenders who can evade justice for years. We also highlight the long-lasting trauma experienced by Donna's family—from their move to Texas, the loss of their stepfather, to their struggle for justice—reminding us that crime not only takes lives but leaves wounds that span generations.


This episode includes AI-generated content.