St. John’s unexpected surge has New York buzzing, but it sparks a bigger debate: what actually counts as ending the city’s championship drought? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down which teams qualify, why fans draw the line at certain leagues, and whether a college title should even be part of the conversation.

The discussion takes a fun turn as they imagine parade routes, revisit past “jinx” moments with New York teams, and compare it all to a bizarre Philly sports debate involving Smarty Jones. It’s a mix of serious sports talk and classic New York radio energy, where even defining a championship turns into a full-blown argument.