In today's duel, Noah Scott (@NoahAScott6) debates with Jim Chatterton (@JimChattertonPL) over how you should approach drafting a catcher in your fantasy drafts. Should you target one of the first five catchers going off the board (Realmuto, Grandal, Perez, Smith, Contreras), or wait and use a late pick to grab a flyer like Sean Murphy or James McCann? They discuss the historical performance of the position, how much of a premium you are paying when you select catchers, and what the opportunity cost is for the different tiers of catcher.

Have a topic you want us to settle? Let us know @PitchersDuel

Intro Music Credit: Cory Yamashiro | @_minoru_music

Find the Short Hops and Tall Tales podcast here: @ShortHopsPL

Get PL+ and join our community!: https://www.pitcherlist.com/plus