This week on Cinema IRL, Scott and Amber are dissecting *Hunting Matthew Nichols*, a film that proves if your brother vanished 22 years ago, maybe just leave the grainy VHS tapes in the evidence box where they belong. They’re following Tara’s ill-advised documentary journey into the woods to find a "destroyed" cabin that apparently has a mind of its own and a very strict policy against unauthorized blood rituals. Between debating the merits of burning down Satan’s real estate and wondering why anyone enters a vacant shack after dark, the duo explores why some cold cases should probably stay frozen.